Round Robin: Allen, Burrow, Lamar...

Flight

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
19,769
Reputation
1,620
Daps
50,638
Reppin
KC
He was clearly missing throws this year that he made last year and there's only one QB in this list that has top tier WR options PLUS we ain't shytting on Kelce like he ain't Kelce. He ain't washed. He has almost 100 receptions this year. You're kicking him to prop Pat up and that's not how it works.

Pat is nowhere near the heights he was in previous years. He only keeps his #1 spot off his history because if I'm ranking it off the actual performance this season he's #4 by a LOT.
He was bad the first six weeks. But since the DHop trade he’s been legitimately good. The issue is he was so bad those first 6 weeks.

And yes Kelce is washed or nearing it. I watch every game…as a chiefs fan I’m telling you he can’t move anymore.
 

Chip Skylark

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jan 2, 2014
Messages
23,721
Reputation
3,891
Daps
65,669
Pat was playing games with Skyy Moore and a washed Kelce as his main receiving options man. Once he got DHop..his TDs went up and picks went way down.

Yep

When it’s time to win. Pat makes it happen


Then this



What are we doing? Lol
 

calh45

Cal
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
11,711
Reputation
2,087
Daps
41,328
He was bad the first six weeks. But since the DHop trade he’s been legitimately good. The issue is he was so bad those first 6 weeks.

And yes Kelce is washed or nearing it. I watch every game…as a chiefs fan I’m telling you he can’t move anymore.

He has been legitimately good, but the other three have been otherworldly in that same span. I'm not saying anything crazy by holding him to his own standards while at the same time comparing him to the other QBs who have played better than him when you look at this whole season. Josh went on an MVP level run. Burrow became the 11th QB to have over 40 touchdowns in a season. Lamar is probably going to be the 12th QB over 40 touchdowns AND potentially set the all time QB rating.

Even with him played better later in this season he has less touchdowns, more interceptions, and is the only one under 100 QB rating for the year. The Chiefs defense is just as responsible for the overall record as Pat. If Lamar or Joe or Josh don't show up their teams don't win. He's still #1, but y'all are being overly sensitive that I'm pointing out a very factual statement about his performance vs the other 3 performances THIS year. He's #1 off legacy and that's fine to say.
 

gtj1982

Superstar
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
5,204
Reputation
850
Daps
15,648
Reppin
America's Darkside--210
He was clearly missing throws this year that he made last year and there's only one QB in this list that has top tier WR options PLUS we ain't shytting on Kelce like he ain't Kelce. He ain't washed. He has almost 100 receptions this year. You're kicking him to prop Pat up and that's not how it works.

Pat is nowhere near the heights he was in previous years. He only keeps his #1 spot off his history because if I'm ranking it off the actual performance this season he's #4 by a LOT.

Kelce is clearly washed. Dude can barely run out there. The fact he has that many receptions is an indictment of what Pat was working with this year.

Lamar is the best QB in the league today though but I would still lean to towards taking burrow or Mahomes if I needed a touchdown to win with less than 2 mins left on the clock.
 

Flight

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
19,769
Reputation
1,620
Daps
50,638
Reppin
KC
Yep

When it’s time to win. Pat makes it happen


Then this



What are we doing? Lol

DHop trade saved him. Now that Hollywood is back too and Worthy has figured it out he looks like a monster again.
 

Blessings

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Feb 25, 2013
Messages
15,853
Reputation
2,458
Daps
45,883
Reppin
NULL
If I'm a defensive coordinator or playing on defense it's:
Lamar
Mahomes
Allen
Burrow

in that order - offensive unit/team agnostic
 

Blessings

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Feb 25, 2013
Messages
15,853
Reputation
2,458
Daps
45,883
Reppin
NULL
Kelce is clearly washed. Dude can barely run out there. The fact he has that many receptions is an indictment of what Pat was working with this year.

Lamar is the best QB in the league today though but I would still lean to towards taking burrow or Mahomes if I needed a touchdown to win with less than 2 mins left on the clock.



Are you saying that because of their current team?
Would you feel that way if Lamar or Josh had Andy as HC?
Would you feel that way if Lamar or Josh had Chase + Higgins as their WRs?
 

STAN JONES

Fire John Harbaugh
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
29,421
Reputation
5,467
Daps
64,422
Reppin
Baltimore
This season’s playoffs would be the perfect opportunity for the question to answer itself if we’re talking full body of work.

Unfortunately, Burrow isn’t going to make it this year to answer it. If they could have only beat the Patriots in the season opener.
Colts just lost :lupe:

the door is WIDE open for a Bengals @ Bills playoff game wildcard weekend

they just need the Dolphins and Broncos to lose 1 game
 

calh45

Cal
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
11,711
Reputation
2,087
Daps
41,328
Colts just lost :lupe:

the door is WIDE open for a Bengals @ Bills playoff game wildcard weekend

they just need the Dolphins and Broncos to lose 1 game

And I don't think Tua isn't starting for Miami. I have no idea if that's a good or bad thing for the Dolphins.
 
Top