I don't like either beat...
Tom's sampling is a bit off...My ears can detect something off with the transitions, and it's annoying...It sounds like the timing of the looping is a little skewed...Also, I hate Premo style production, when the sample get's chopped to either one or two bars, and then replayed as a new melody...It rarely sounds nice...
Bigrod's beat just isn't my style, but I give him the win because it sounds like it involved more creativity, with the drum fills, and the changing patterns, and it sounds like an original composition...