Robert Garcia says "Floyd is the greatest fighter of all time"

seemorecizzy

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,413
Reputation
2,351
Daps
53,049
Reppin
NULL
Wait.....some of you have Floyd as maybe a top 20-25 fighter? :stopitslime:

Man forget all of that junk, PLEASE name 19-24 fighters BETTER than Floyd. Come on man:snoop:

Greb better than Mayweather?:what: @Newzz are you serious? He fought in the 1920's.
hatred over common sense in this thread breh
 

Newzz

"The Truth" always prevails
Supporter
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
44,924
Reputation
7,470
Daps
104,634
Wait.....some of you have Floyd as a top 20-25 fighter? :stopitslime:

Man forget all of that junk, PLEASE name 19-24 fighters BETTER than Floyd. Come on man:snoop:

Greb better than Mayweather?:what: @Newzz are you serious? He fought in the 1920's.

What's next....Sugar Ray Robinson fought in the 40's?:comeon:

Harry Greb has one of the best resumes EVER. Fought 48 fights against HOF opposition alone in his career....Floyd has 46 fights total.

Greb had a record of 33-9-6 over those matchups against HOFers.

Not only that, I believe he was the ONLY man to ever beat Gene Tunney (one of the top 7 Heavyweights of all-time) well:usure:

Hell yeah, Harry Greb has a better resume than Floyd and is ranked accordingly as a Top 5 boxer ever:wtf:
 

mcellas

Superstar
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
13,391
Reputation
4,484
Daps
31,515
Reppin
Miami
So this what you do breh?? Cant win an argument so you resort to lying??

What I said repeatedly was that Floyd could've fought Cotto/Margarito/Shane after his fight with Oscar and matched what he made fighting Hatton, But he chose to duck Oops I mean retire for two years instead while everyone fought each other

So you are saying that Cotto/Margarito/Shane fell off out of their primes when Floyd fought them?
Floyd beat em all what about his prime :sas2:
 

Black_Jesus

Superstar
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
16,281
Reputation
723
Daps
21,254
Reppin
from the home of coca-cola, i'm not referring to s
So you are saying that Cotto/Margarito/Shane fell off out of their primes when Floyd fought them?
Floyd beat em all what about his prime :sas2:

Thats exactly what im saying.. by the time floyd fought shane he was pushing 40 and had been inactive for almost two years... Cotto got decimated by Marg and Pacquiao...
Floyds prime?? Its not a fair question because everyone else mentioned in this thread has been twice ass active as he has since he retired (the 1st time)
 

RedBull

All Star
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
3,998
Reputation
704
Daps
10,794
Reppin
On KRS One's nose, eating sunflower seeds.
What's next....Sugar Ray Robinson fought in the 40's?:comeon:

Harry Greb has one of the best resumes EVER. Fought 48 fights against HOF opposition alone in his career....Floyd has 46 fights total.

Greb had a record of 33-9-6 over those matchups against HOFers.

Not only that, I believe he was the ONLY man to ever beat Gene Tunney (one of the top 7 Heavyweights of all-time) well:usure:

Hell yeah, Harry Greb has a better resume than Floyd and is ranked accordingly as a Top 5 boxer ever:wtf:




staring-o.gif
 
Joined
Jul 26, 2012
Messages
1,373
Reputation
100
Daps
1,678
Reppin
NULL
When he came back two years later.
What was the reason he left again? :lupe:

How bout the second time? :lupe:
I don't know. I just know your reason is fairly stupid since the division was just as strong upon his return.
 
Last edited:

Big Boss

Veteran
Joined
Sep 26, 2012
Messages
177,296
Reputation
12,670
Daps
346,018
Reppin
NULL
Too be fair to Floyd, and just judging him off of "names" and using no context (like most people do for old-timers), his resume is:

He's 46-0 and has fought 21 World Champions (either current/former/would go on to become Champion).

It's great, imo, which is why I have him in the Top 15-25 range All-Time. I just cant see him sneaking into the Top 5 which is where the GOAT discussion takes place.

He would have to do something spectacular.

Beat manny and bradley at 147

Beat cotto(again) and ggg at 160.

Beat ward, froch, and chavez jr at 168.

Beat hopkins, stevenson, and kovalev at 175.
 

Newzz

"The Truth" always prevails
Supporter
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
44,924
Reputation
7,470
Daps
104,634
He would have to do something spectacular.

Beat manny and bradley at 147

Beat cotto(again) and ggg at 160.

Beat ward, froch, and chavez jr at 168.

Beat hopkins, stevenson, and kovalev at 175.

I wouldn't even go that far:manny:

Beat Manny at 147
Beat Cotto at 160 for belt
Beat GGG at 154 catchweight since he offered to fight him there
Beat B-Hop at 160 catchweight since he offered to fight him there
Beat SOG at 160 catchweight SOG offered to fight him there
 

Big Boss

Veteran
Joined
Sep 26, 2012
Messages
177,296
Reputation
12,670
Daps
346,018
Reppin
NULL
I wouldn't even go that far:manny:

Beat Manny at 147
Beat Cotto at 160 for belt
Beat GGG at 154 catchweight since he offered to fight him there
Beat B-Hop at 160 catchweight since he offered to fight him there
Beat SOG at 160 catchweight SOG offered to fight him there

cant disagree with that:ehh:
 
Top