Remember when eminem was a producer?

[Lucky Millionaire]

He wasn't that bad IMO he just peaked reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeally early

Looking at that wiki page 02-04 were his best years as a solo producer then it's downhill from there

 

[Ian1362]

he is a terrible producer

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmVCUOzD5QA]The Game ft. Eminem - We Ain't [The Documentary] - YouTube[/ame]

that shyt sounds like poor-man impersonation of half-assed Erik Sermon beats from 1994. Thankfully real producers contributed a bunch of great production to the album.

 

[OnlyInCalifornia]

Probably the most garbage run from any producer giving beats to good artists ever.

 

[TJ Hend]

most his beats were trash/generic

people gave him credit because he was eminem

 

[Busby]

If you didn't like his beat for Runnin y'all nikkas are trippin...



His beat for Pac's Ghost was



I mean shyt...Kanye West called Em one of the best producers out there..he nearly stole one of his beat CD's when he was working on D-12's album...

 

[Spurs91]

Lose yourself, 8 mile, the way i am, renegade, criminal, marshall mathers, dont approach me, american physco, devils night, sing for the moment, til i collapse, patiently waiting, welcome 2 detroit........

 

[mortuus est]

Some are ok but didnt he have them ghost producers he's been riding with for years helping him out most of the time

 

[Bigbigguy]

The beats em did for GRODT >>>

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9_eVNRplNY]50 Cent Ft. Eminem - Patiently Waiting [Get Rich Or Die Trying] - YouTube[/ame]



Banks





Em is a dope producer stop hating

 

[JoelB]

He wasn't that bad ...

 

[Zach Lowe]

@Bigbigguy

Kwame/K1 did On Fire
Em just added some instruments to it or something

 

[Ian1362]

His beat for Pac's Ghost was

Tupac - Ghost - YouTube

I mean shyt...Kanye West called Em one of the best producers out there..he nearly stole one of his beat CD's when he was working on D-12's album...

Beat for Ghost is trash with cheesy drums and near exact-same progression (keys, dark bass) as most of Runnin.

Running is basically a looped up Edgar Winter chorus

Jeff Bass produced most of the Eminem singles like someone a few pages back noted that people keep linking as evidence of his talent.

Kanye also called Swizz Beatz the GOAT

I've never heard any other producer ever talk glowingly about Eminem's production.

 

[Reggie]

Em was pretty hit or miss when it came to beats. Some of his beats are some bangers and some are some duds and repetitive as hell. I didn't mind him producing unlike i lot of people i know.

 

[OnlyInCalifornia]

He also didn't do 'Lose Yourself' himself either.

 

[Zach Lowe]

He sounds like what I imagine Dre would sound like with no ghost/co-producers

 

[Harry B]

he produced almost all of slim shady lp and marshall mathers lp.... not bad

It was the bass brothers who did most of it, he did start producing on Eminem Show though.. I'd assume that Mr. Porter and other cats did most of it though he might've been in the studio telling cats how he wanted it to sound like a "real producer" though.

Just look at

9. "Drips" (featuring Obie Trice) Mathers, Obie Trice, Denaun Porter, Bass Eminem

eminem is the only one credited as produced but Mr. Porter and one of the bass brothers are "writers" .


If we ignore the fact that the bass brothers and Mr. Porter were on every joint he had a lot of dope beats. Beats perfectly made for his style.
Eminem spits the best over "on the low" beats, it shouldn't be a lot of sounds and hsit like that. Him over Kanye beats would probably be meh. But any top notch lyricist over Eminem beats is almost a given classic like the 3 joints Jay did (8 mile, Renegade and Moment of Clarity), The Cross by Nas..