Lord_nikon
Veteran
Most sad and painful shyt I ever seen
Good film nevertheless
Good film nevertheless
Wikipedia. They have the meatric score.
That shyt look like it's gonna make me
A great film that I will never voluntarily watch again. Any child can fall victim to the circumstance of Seita and Setsuko in a war environment. Millions actually have. Kinda stuff that is easier to read in history textbooks than to actually see before your eyes in individual cases.
Seita is a good kid who makes bad decisions out of pride and pays for those choices with the lives of his sister and himself. He moves out of a relatively safe home that provides food, shelter, general caretaking for them without any labour in return to live independently in a cave. God awful choice. but you can understand it because he's a kid who doesn't understand the reality of the world he was born into and is constantly trying to repress the trauma he's experiencing to appear strong in front of his sister (how many dead bodies does he see without changing expressions? Kid is extremely warped). But he's not a shounen hero who can break through obstacles and there is no deus ex machina to bail him out of problems. And I can't really even blame people for not helping those kids when their tomorrow isn't promised either. Not fair. But it's real.
Lot of viewers wind up hating the caretaker for the children. But just about everything she says is the truth and her attitude is warranted considering the circumstances. Harsh, but not wrong. Most of the adults in the film are this way. No heroes with capes.
I'm giving it a 9. Only thing keeping it from a 10 is the 0 rewatch value and that it seems intended to make the viewer irritated in some way. Very similar to Now and Then, Here and There in that constant sense of dread and basically nothing going right. Anyone who likes this film should give that a try.
Of the Ghibli Films, I think this is my second or third favorite. When Marnie Was There is the best, Princess Mononoke somewhere behind it with Grave of the Fireflies.