Rate this anime day 3: Full Metal Alchemist (Brotherhood)

[Anerdyblackguy]

Possibly the best anime of all time. Plus, it follows the manga perfectly.

If you haven't seen this, I envy you

OP please add me

Got you.

 

[Sterling Archer]

FMA 2003 is better

Nah. I admit there are a couple things that I liked in the OG that werent possible to have in Brotherhood because of the story being different but it was in no way better.

 

[Sterling Archer]

This right here

Spoiler

Easily a top 20 anime for me.

The way he did Envy tho...:letitburn:

 

[Freedman]

One of the GOATs
10/10

 

[Ms. Quick]

:letitburn:

 

[Software]

Spoiler

@For Da Bag

@number144 @Lord-Yosh @Balla @Rusty Kuntz

@KingJay

@The Darkness Monster

@Bart simpson

If you want to be tagged in future rate anime threads let me know.

nikka wtf you already know I should be tagged

Also fukk that nikka Stark he wasn't even that strong

 

[Ironman]

Easily 10.

There are many scenes got sad but there's one scene got me heated as fukk and angry at the same time I was and at that person......If y'all know what scene I was talking about.

There's only two scenes that put me in this place

 

[Anerdyblackguy]

nikka wtf you already know I should be tagged

Also fukk that nikka Stark he wasn't even that strong

The disrespect to the number 1 espada.

 

[xXMASHERXx]

Great anime but I don't know if I can put it in my top 5 or 10 but I feel giving it anything less than a 8 is an insult. I'll give it a 9.

 

[MischievousMonkey]

Nah. I admit there are a couple things that I liked in the OG that werent possible to have in Brotherhood because of the story being different but it was in no way better.

Tone, pacing and character development are very impactful for me so it makes sense I prefer the first iteration.

If Brotherhood tone was fixed it would make it so much better than it is.

 

[Sterling Archer]

Tone, pacing and character development are very impactful for me so it makes sense I prefer the first iteration.

If Brotherhood tone was fixed it would make it so much better than it is.

And thats what I mean by some elements from the first were missing from brotherhood. Like say, Izumi's story being more emotional in the OG and the tone that lended itself to the original in various character arcs but even still, taking that into consideration, it isnt superior to Brotherhood. I understood what you meant.

 

[humminbird]

10
an actual show with brothers being brothers and not fighting to the death.
Great story and backdrop
Great twists and turns.
Great ending.
makes the 2003 version look like Teletubbies.
the goat anime to me.

 

[Software]

The disrespect to the number 1 espada.

Akatsuki > Organization XIII > Ginyu Force >>>> The Espada

 

[Anti-Anime]

Mods move this shyt to the film room

Let these weeabc00ns weeab out in there

 

[Steel]

Op Code Geas should be up next