[POLL & DISCUSSION] Best Live Action Spiderman

[Alpha Male]

Who is responsible for your favorite live action portrayal of Peter Parker / Spiderman?


Tobey Maguire

Andrew Garfield

Tom Holland

 

[parallax]

Anyone but McGuire

 

[KravenMorehead™]

Tom Holland.

 

[FlyRy]

I don't know about all that, but I know which actor was in the best movies :gandalf:

 

[Soymuscle Mike]

Tie between TH and AG.

For the poll's sake I'll give the edge to TH for that scene where he got stuck under the rubble, that shyt was cold.

Toby did what the scripts asked of him, but as an adaptation of Peter Parker /Spiderman since first watch I've watched those movies like:

 

[OJ Simpsom]

Holland's performance made me feel like I was watching the OG Spider-man cartoon back in the day.

 

[Alpha Male]

See for me Tobey is still the best.

I thought he was the most pure and innocent, like he just had an innate selflessness about him.

Of the three I believe he would put others before himself the most, he felt like the most natural hero.

 

[Rekkapryde]

Garfield.

 

[Roman Brady]

Garfield.

You already know, tobey had the only great movie (spiderman2) and Holland has a shot to surpass them both but homecoming did neither

 

[Achille]

Nicholas Hammond should be added to list.

 

[Alpha Male]

Nicholas Hammond should be added to list.

No joke this was actually the first time I ever laid eyes on Spiderman.

I was like 4 years old and my mother rented a VHS of the old 60's captain america cartoon and I remember there being an advert for this show before the actual cartoon started.

No lie those real shots of dude climbing the building had me like

 

[Achille]

No joke this was actually the first time I ever laid eyes on Spiderman.

I was like 4 years old and my mother rented a VHS of the old 60's captain america cartoon and I remember there being an advert for this show before the actual cartoon started.

No lie those real shots of dude climbing the building had me like

Same here as a youngin all these old live action shows Spider-man, Hulk, Captain America, Wonder Woman had me like . The technology wasn't there with those shows but at least they did what they could practical at the time. I still feel the newer live action flicks could do some practical effects as well to make things more unique at times. Not everything needs to be CGI.

 

[MartyMcFly]

Either Garfield or Holland. I voted for Holland though because I absolutely adore this movie but seriously its a toss up for me. And I've already stated ad nauseam why I love the two of them and why I never got into Tobey. Like I said, this isn't some new shyt. I didn't fukk with him when I was 16, I just put up with it because he was spider man. Andrew and Tom are both the peter parker i think of in my head when I'm reading. They embody his worst qualities and his best qualities while also understanding spider man has to have a certain amount of cockiness and attitude

See for me Tobey is still the best.

I thought he was the most pure and innocent, like he just had an innate selflessness about him.

Of the three I believe he would put others before himself the most, he felt like the most natural hero.

Thats just it breh: Peter isn't a natural hero. When peter first gets his powers, whats his first thought?



The only reason that changed is because he saw how his selfishness has an impact on those around him and he learned that lesson the hard way. He's a guy who is good, yes, but he's constantly learning what it means to be a hero and how to do the right thing.

 

[Lootpack]

I'm digging Holland's performance more for the long run. Minus some miscasts here and there, Homecoming felt like Spectacular overall and his portrayal stayed true to the comics for the most part.

 

[Ill Lou Malnati]

Haven't seen Homecoming, but I can definitely say Garfield >>> Maguire. HATED the casting of Tobey and Dunst. They were terrible in all three films.