I've never played Fallout 3, does that mean I'm not a real gamer anymore?
I own Rage and Skyrim tho and from what I hear the game seems similar to those games. 
(Same developer)
 
Red Dead was probably the most unique/interesting game I've played this gen though, In fact, if it was a movie it would probably be regarded as the greatest 
western film ever
 I give it two thumbs up.