Their building wasn't insured?
Pastor obviously has family that are roofers cutting him a hell of a deal$4.4M for a roof?
Maybe if it's the roof of the Sistine Chapel or Westminster Abbey. Definitely not for any normal church.
I'd ask to see the estimate from the roofers. Then, I'd let the deacons all go out and solicit quotes from roofing companies. Match up the prices against how they're reviewed online and make a choice. Bet it ain't $4.4M.