It's not even close. "Felicity" is a good show for the ENTIRE series. A lot of folks seems to think "Dawson's Creek" is only good the first 2 seasons.
I cannot fukking believe "Felicity" only has 6.6 score on IMDB. It should definitely have a score in at least in the high 7's. It should have a score comparable to "Gilmore Girls", which has a 8.0 score.
My nikka if you can watch "Dawson's Creek", you can most definitely watch "Felicity".
I own both shows on DVD & have watched both of them back-to-back in the last few years. So I can definitely say:
"Felicity" >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "Dawson's Creek"
"Felicity" is just a better written show.
and like
@dem bath salts said, "Felicity" actually has black folks in it, like Donald Faison (Turk from "Scrubs" & Murray from "Clueless") as a recurring character for 23 episodes.