one gotta go: Lord of the Rings, the Hobbit or Harry Potter

[MartyMcFly]

i know different strokes for....but
how can you put The hobbit over lotr? i like the hobbit but still..... Never seen HP (cant stand kids acting or singing)

Oh I misread my bad. I didn't know it was three choices. Well then the hobbit has to go. But I thought the point of this thread was only one can survive. I didn't even see the hobbit as an option

 

[AyBrehHam Linkin]

Hobbit easy

Hobbits are Dwarves

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

I'm picking between Harry Potter, something I love and lord of the rings, something I like. Of course I'm serious

U love Harry potter mcfly?


I hate that Harry potter shyt, I ain't never seen the hobbit but fukk them both, to the bushes they go

 

[MartyMcFly]

U love Harry potter mcfly?


I hate that Harry potter shyt, I ain't never seen the hobbit but fukk them both, to the bushes they go

Love Harry Potter homie. Lol I got a Hogwarts varsity jacket from hot topic.

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

Love Harry Potter homie. Lol I got a Hogwarts varsity jacket from hot topic.

no hate u got good taste other than that.

But yeah....

 

[NobodyReally]

Hobbit was dope to me.

Get LOTR da fukk up outa here

 

[MartyMcFly]

no hate u got good taste other than that.

But yeah....

Appreciate it breh. I love what I love :whoknows:

The jacket is tough though

 

[NobodyReally]

Definitely The Hobbit, but as a die-hard Harry Potter book fan, I have to say those movies didn't do the books justice and should have been done LOTR style. But they weren't, so film wise, LOTR movies take the cake for me.

 

[MartyMcFly]

Definitely The Hobbit, but as a die-hard Harry Potter book fan, I have to say those movies didn't do the books justice and should have been done LOTR style. But they weren't, so film wise, LOTR movies take the cake for me.

Ok quesrion: is it possible to look at the films as adaptations of the books rather than slavish translations tho? The first two movies are slavish to the books and in my opinion, they suffer because of it. Not saying they're bad but there's too much in them. Whereas the third one is possibly the best one and it cuts a lot from the book and it's when the series starts to find its own identity

 

[FlyRy]

I'm picking between Harry Potter, something I love and lord of the rings, something I like. Of course I'm serious

Pick Hobbit over oscar winning movies brehs

 

[MartyMcFly]

Pick Hobbit over oscar winning movies brehs

Douche lol. Didn't you see me say I didn't know hobbit was an option? I changed my pick. But I'd pick Harry over all three

 

[NobodyReally]

Ok quesrion: is it possible to look at the films as adaptations of the books rather than slavish translations tho? The first two movies are slavish to the books and in my opinion, they suffer because of it. Not saying they're bad but there's too much in them. Whereas the third one is possibly the best one and it cuts a lot from the book and it's when the series starts to find its ownt identity

I know, I know. I can't let it go though. Yes, movies are supposed to be adaptations. But I still think the Jackson did a much better job overall of adapting than the writers/directors of the entire HP series, with the exception of Cuaron, because you're right, the 3rd one was brilliant.

 

[Exit9NJturnpike]

Easily Harry Potter

 

[Still FloW]

DOPE part of the Hobbit was with the ELVES, i love those nikkas..

same with LOTR, damn elves so graceful..

Harry Potter is #1 for me... so Hobbit gotta go

 

[Sensitive Blake Griffin]

hobbit was garbage, it shouldn't even be in contention