1. They didn't handle it righteously according to their own laws by bringing Malcolm in front of the congregation and holding trial over his accusations against Elijah Muhammad.
2. The NOI became a COINTELPRO organization that worked with the FBI, KKK & other CAC organizations.
3. Malcolm said himself that the NOI had become a criminal Enterprise. If you look into the (Philly) Black Mafia you will see that many high ranking NOI members were heavily involved in the drug trade and contract killing.
4 .The NOI as Malcom stated were only ever called to take up arms against "traitor" members, but never against the Klan or Police even when members were attacked. They have always been absent when it comes to fighting for our rights and protecting the community.
5. They claim Elijah Muhammad was a divine prophet and Master Card was the Supreme Being in the flesh. They're basically the black Scientology.
1. I am not a follower of the NOI, so I don't know the full allegations made against him and by whom.I do know that Malcolm was a straight arrow, and those in the organization who weren't, had an incentive to see him ousted.
2. I need proof that Cointel co-opted the leadership of the NOI. without that proof, your comment is intentionally misleading. feds had spies inside of every powerful Black organization. Having agents infiltrating a group doesn't make it a cointelpro organization .
NOI leadership aka Elijah Muhammad worked briefly with white separatist organizations to achieve the same goals..separation of races. At the time, NOI leadership was really about that and made efforts to get govt . to allocate territory for African Americans to create separate state.
3. See #1.......NOI initially recruited from jails and the segments of society that were labeled the bottom. Majority of those men reformed themselves, but some fell back into their old criminal lifestyles.
4. Malcolm did address this as one of the problems he had with NOI leadership, and his speaking out against it probably created problems for him later. Though I wouldn't go so far as to say that they didn't bang against white racists. NOI had branches across the south during civil rights era... and you won't read many accounts of klan or police attacking them down there. White people didn't want those problems, the threat of retaliation was the reason. Other Black self defense groups
existed down there that would bust shots.
Fighting for rights ? NOI as it existed when Malcolm was alive did not get involved in political demonstrations (or the political process, I think)
Protecting the community? Fruit of Islam was created as the muscle / military / police of the NOI The areas where the NOI operated in the city I grew up in were clean and safe...even at height of crack era. Same city where some of X's assassins were from, by coincidence.
5. Again, not follower so don't know what they believe, but to a non Christian....the stories of the bible would seem odd..