I'm not say thing I think it's right, or the right call, just this is how these people who are incredibly devoted to free press and journalism think, sometimes it goes too far. Calling a paper fascist and condemning it entirely for this is just not accurate. It's good to see the writers, like Dargis, pushing back. Maybe they'll pull it. You really think the editor of the Opinion page is a secret fascist and this is what he wanted to promote? These people have their own extremities on topics like freedom of the press and real journalism, it gives them blind spots.
Now, is the collateral damage of this too high? Probably, I'll support pulling it and an apology, but I'm not going to not read the NY Times because of an op ed.