Both men have different stories about how the confrontation started but both agree that it was fueled by road rage, that they were brake-checking each other, driving too fast and that Allison's wife flipped off the Hales, according to police records obtained by USA TODAY.
At some point, Allison, his family members, and an independent witness told police that Hale became the aggressor, trying to run Allison off the road, chasing him down, and throwing a water bottle into his driver's side window.
That's when Allison grabbed his gun and fired, hitting Hale's 5-year-old daughter in the lower leg. Allison later told police he was aiming at the lower rear truck bed.
"After he shot, my daughter is screaming," Hale told police. "It was an instant reaction."
So Hale grabbed his own gun from his center console and emptied the Glock 43, firing seven to eight rounds at Allison's car, Hale told police.
One of the bullets hit Allison's 14-year-old daughter in the back.
"It hurts!" Allison's' daughter yelled on body camera footage of the incident.
"I don’t want to die," Hale's 5-year-old can be heard saying on a 911 call, according to WJXT-TV.
Both girls were treated for their injuries later at local hospitals and survived.
At the time of the melee, police arrested both men on attempted murder charges, saying they "intentionally committed an act" that could have killed the girls.
"The act was imminently dangerous and demonstrated a depraved mind without regard for human life," police wrote.
That was October. Now, Hale is the only man facing charges.
The Nassau County State's Attorney's Office charged him on March 30 with three counts of second-degree attempted murder, three counts of aggravated assault, and one count of maliciously throwing a deadly missile.
That last charge stems from Hale allegedly throwing a water bottle into Allison's car.
Allison told police that though the water bottle did not hurt him or cause him to lose control of the vehicle, it "stunned me so bad I grabbed my pistol," and that he fired at Hale's car to "get out of the whole situation."
Allison is protected from being charged himself under Florida's Stand Your Ground Law, according to the Nassau County State's Attorney's Office.
"Florida courts have held that the throwing of a water bottle or similar object could form the basis of a forcible felony," according to a disposition statement written by Assistant State Attorney Christopher Roth Huband on March 31.
"The water bottle had liquid in it, and (Hale) threw it with malicious intent, clearly intending for it to enter the Allisons’ vehicle and possibly strike one of the occupants," Huband wrote. "As such, the water bottle would qualify as a deadly missile."
www.yahoo.com
