Nothing is more spookier than October baseball -OFFICIAL 2023 MLB PLAYOFFS THREAD

Dipsey Doo

Superstar
Bushed
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
4,382
Reputation
1,486
Daps
15,071
Reppin
Atlanta
It's already too late, but it's crazy to me that all of the 100 win teams this season, combined to win just 1 playoff game.

I don't think it's fair to the teams with the best record to have to sit for a week, while the lower seeded teams play and stay in their routine.

Baseball needs to less teams in the postseason, not more.
 

Spence

Superstar
Joined
Jul 14, 2015
Messages
18,035
Reputation
2,982
Daps
46,921
It's already too late, but it's crazy to me that all of the 100 win teams this season, combined to win just 1 playoff game.

I don't think it's fair to the teams with the best record to have to sit for a week, while the lower seeded teams play and stay in their routine.

Baseball needs to less teams in the postseason, not more.
What’s your proposal to fix it?
I think the only thing you can do is force the next game to happen the day after any team is eliminated to make sure the wild card teams are at a disadvantage which is technically what’s supposed to happen.

The only thing wrong with that is it gives hitters additional games to stay in rhythm or work through slumps to get ready for the playoffs.

They should probably bring back the play in game then get right on into the division instead of making it best of 3. Then make the DS games 7 instead of 5 so the lay off teams get their groove back.
 

Mike_Pipeson

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Oct 22, 2017
Messages
10,368
Reputation
1,034
Daps
23,494
Reppin
HTX
I think we need to stop the narrative that's going on now that baseball doesn't need a bye. Astros been getting byes and doing fine but it seems people either forget that LA will ALWAYS, without fail, choke.
Braves usually follows suit but they actually have a legitimate ring.

Media needs to stop hyping up proven chokers and so expectations can be more realistic :ufdup:
 

Dipsey Doo

Superstar
Bushed
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
4,382
Reputation
1,486
Daps
15,071
Reppin
Atlanta
What’s your proposal to fix it?
I think the only thing you can do is force the next game to happen the day after any team is eliminated to make sure the wild card teams are at a disadvantage which is technically what’s supposed to happen.

The only thing wrong with that is it gives hitters additional games to stay in rhythm or work through slumps to get ready for the playoffs.

They should probably bring back the play in game then get right on into the division instead of making it best of 3. Then make the DS games 7 instead of 5 so the lay off teams get their groove back.

I thought the WC play in and going to the Division series a day after was the best format.

I also liked the 2020 COVID tournament format - I thought that was the most fair considering the circumstances.

I understand why MLB wants more teams involved and more postseason games ($$$). Giving a team a week off (especially since baseball is a sport that is played EVERY DAY) is more of a competitive disadvantage than anything.

My solution - do away with the byes. Every team plays a best of 3 first round series, then a five game Division series, then 7 game championships series and World Series.
 

Spence

Superstar
Joined
Jul 14, 2015
Messages
18,035
Reputation
2,982
Daps
46,921
I thought the WC play in and going to the Division series a day after was the best format.

I also liked the 2020 COVID tournament format - I thought that was the most fair considering the circumstances.

I understand why MLB wants more teams involved and more postseason games ($$$). Giving a team a week off (especially since baseball is a sport that is played EVERY DAY) is more of a competitive disadvantage than anything.

My solution - do away with the byes. Every team plays a best of 3 first round series, then a five game Division series, then 7 game championships series and World Series.
The key is to have the lower seeds burn their best starter (or two) which means they come in punching left handed. MLB just needs to make the DS the day after elimination to prevent any resets
 

Super Cheech

I Feel So Westcoast
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
8,560
Reputation
2,175
Daps
17,224
Reppin
Los Angeles / SOHH Icey
IMG_0102.jpeg


:blessed:
 

Dorian Breh

Veteran
Joined
Jan 14, 2016
Messages
22,389
Reputation
13,663
Daps
112,023
I thought the WC play in and going to the Division series a day after was the best format.

I also liked the 2020 COVID tournament format - I thought that was the most fair considering the circumstances.

I understand why MLB wants more teams involved and more postseason games ($$$). Giving a team a week off (especially since baseball is a sport that is played EVERY DAY) is more of a competitive disadvantage than anything.

My solution - do away with the byes. Every team plays a best of 3 first round series, then a five game Division series, then 7 game championships series and World Series.


So Atlanta can start their offseason even sooner?

Sheesh
 

god shamgod

Veteran
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
33,527
Reputation
4,196
Daps
97,788
In their eight NLDS games against the Phillies over the past two years, the Braves hit just .183 with eight homers, 21 runs and a .556 OPS, and struck out 77 times in 257 at-bats. After assuming they had reached a nadir of sorts in last year’s NLDS, the Braves were even worse this time, slugging .264 to last year’s .344, and hitting three homers to last year’s five.

:huhldup: This is utter dominance bu but the offense didn’t show up. No shyt they got shut tf down
 
Top