Post and talk about any MVP's in NFL history that you believed should not have won it. Even though Peyton is my dude, and so was Air McNair in 03, but I remember believing that Priest Holmes or even Jamal Lewis should have won it. 03 was a great and one of the best RB year's in recent history. Also, I think in 08 it probably should have been Rivers, even though the Chargers record wasn't that great if I remember correctly. lol I remember Jets fans were saying that Chad Pennington should have won it in 08. Also, Adrian Peterson had a great year too in 08. Which NFL MVP's do you not agree with or not co-sign?