Rolling Stone never pretended to know hip hop. They sort of always knew they didn’t know shyt
pitchfork I hate as they come with this arrogance that they know hip hop when they’re the types that only got into hip hop post Kanye and don’t know real MCing, the culture
what also I’ve noticed is modern non hip hop culture critics look down on rapping that floats between different subject matters in a verse and prefer where it sticks to a certain subject matter not understanding the free form nature of hip hop rhyming
I have no problems with them reviewing Hip Hop. My issue is when these entities label an album as "the most misogynist album of all time" knowing that it's a Hip Hop album and knowing that it's beating a dead horse discussing misogyny in Hip Hop. Then when Nas has songs where he's uplifting women and talking about relationships in a positive light, only an idiot would write a think piece about an album being the most misogynist album ever.