Nas "I Am" got 4.5 Mic when it came out. WHY DOES THE COLI&the internet HATE IT?!

TheDarceKnight

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
29,370
Reputation
13,075
Daps
91,588
Reppin
Jiu Jitsu
The album was critically acclaimed and one of the most commercially successful albums of 99.
The anticipation for it was huge. Nas is Like. The Bootleg.
I desperately tried to like the retail album. I gave it months. Ultimately I had to accept the fact that it wasn't anywhere near a 4.5 mic album. :mjcry:
Ghetto Prisoners :PHandsup:
You Won't See Me Tonight :Pgtfoh:
I Want to Talk to You :PHandsup:
Dr. Knockboot :PHandsup:
Life Is What you Make it :PHandsup:

Big Things :PPicard:
:PPicard::PPicard::PPicard::PPicard:

KISSING :Pgtfoh:

Money is My bytch :PHandsup:
Damn, a lot of brehs are saying they don't fukk with Life is What You Make It in here huh?

Ya'll really think it's that bad?

:picard:
 

Trace

All Star
Joined
Jun 10, 2017
Messages
1,244
Reputation
302
Daps
2,868
Reppin
NY
Song is just average, they could have done better but it isn't terrible, worse things have emerged from both albums that you can blatantly tell this is far below Nas' normal quality output. There's Nastradamus title track, I Wanna Talk To You, Big Things, Big Girl, Quiet nikkas just to name a few.
 

Pop123

Peace
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
29,414
Reputation
6,720
Daps
111,434
Reppin
NULL
Why are the crackers opinions at The Source at the time any more redeeming than yours or mine? In their opinion it was a 4.5. They are wrong, in my opinion. :yeshrug:. I Am is my least favorite Nas album. Production is triggidy
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,469
Reputation
3,946
Daps
48,377
Reppin
NULL
Why are the crackers opinions at The Source at the time any more redeeming than yours or mine? In their opinion it was a 4.5. They are wrong, in my opinion. :yeshrug:. I Am is my least favorite Nas album. Production is triggidy

Not that it makes the opinion more or less valid, but a cracker did not review that album. Carlito Rodriguez did and he's not a cracker.
 

prophecypro

Hollywood North
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
28,223
Reputation
2,693
Daps
60,599
Reppin
LDN
Damn, a lot of brehs are saying they don't fukk with Life is What You Make It in here huh?

Ya'll really think it's that bad?

:picard:

It was always dope to me. Maybe the beat people might not like but for its time I thought it was cool
Nas and X were more narratiing street life perspective on it and I kinda liked for that
 

prophecypro

Hollywood North
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
28,223
Reputation
2,693
Daps
60,599
Reppin
LDN
Damn so interesting

I assumed the album was the bootleg version cause the review came out like a month before the release but reading it again it includes all the songs there on the retail

:jbhmm:


I mean Source did give the Hot Boys and Made Men albums 4 and a half mics that year and Black Rob (though Im sure that was for the advance/bootleg cause that was months out from the retail)

So maybe they just liked what Nas was on :ehh:

I mean Source gave Untitled and Kingdom Come four and a half mics years later so you never know
 

OHSNAP!

Superstar
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
6,792
Reputation
390
Daps
12,726
Reppin
NULL
Damn so interesting

I assumed the album was the bootleg version cause the review came out like a month before the release but reading it again it includes all the songs there on the retail

:jbhmm:


I mean Source did give the Hot Boys and Made Men albums 4 and a half mics that year and Black Rob (though Im sure that was for the advance/bootleg cause that was months out from the retail)

So maybe they just liked what Nas was on :ehh:

I mean Source gave Untitled and Kingdom Come four and a half mics years later so you never know
STFU fukkboi, Guerilla Warfare was a way hotter/harder album than I Am
 

prophecypro

Hollywood North
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
28,223
Reputation
2,693
Daps
60,599
Reppin
LDN
STFU fukkboi, Guerrilla Warfare was a way hotter/harder album than I Am

:mjlol:

I knew the southern dudes would get mad at that one but that raised a few eyebrows at the time , luckily retrospect history on y'all side cause the south won and all that

Im just saying they was giving a lot of 4.5 mics a lot at the time, I love the album too:pachaha:
 

Homeboy Runny-Ray

From Around The Way
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
20,724
Reputation
-954
Daps
20,096
Reppin
Classic Niccas
I knew the southern dudes would get mad at that one but that raised a few eyebrows at the time , luckily retrospect history on y'all side cause the south won and all that

Im just saying they was giving a lot of 4.5 mics a lot at the time, I love the album too


im not from the south and the south aint win chit.

but hot boys guerilla warfare is a CLASSIC and was far superior to "I Am".

they should've gave it 5.
 
Top