Dwight Howard
Superstar
I'd go with VY
Marcus Spears proclaims Steve 'Air' McNair Best College QB EVER
Amare's Right Hook
Southeast World Champion
McNair
Mike Vick?
Tommie Frazier. 3 Straight BCS Championship games, won the last 2. 45-4 record.
Henry Orbit
Wave Gods
I had this cover as a kid and I remember following his stats that season. He was amazing. Wanted my team to draft him (took Kerry Collins instead).
I don't know if we'll ever see another HBCU player again get Heisman votes, he should have won it over Rashaan Salaam that season
I don't know if we'll ever see another HBCU player again get Heisman votes, he should have won it over Rashaan Salaam that season
sidenikkagawd
We want all the smoke
Deshaun Watson was the 1st QB to put up 4k passing and 1 rushing plus he beat Bama when people thought they were invincible.
Vince Young always gonna be #1 for me but i respect McNair and im not mad at people saying he was the best. i think Deshaun Watson has a good argument too
The lack of hype Deshaun Watson got is truly the most baffling thing to me. Manziel was jocked for beating Bama in the regular season. Watson had Nick Saban so shook in the first chip game that Saban kicked an onside kick with 10 minutes left in the 4th. Dude straight up said we ain't stopping this nikka anyways it doesn't matter if he gets the ball on the 20 or the 50 fukk it might as well gamble and get the ball back.
SpursFanSinceNovember2017
Superstar
Cardale Jones
Cam Newton
Vince Young
Cam Newton
Vince Young
Last edited:
staticshock
Veteran
Only FCS player to ever get invited to NY for the Heisman ceremony. He would have won if he went to big white school.
Lot of you gumps don’t know your peoples history tho
Lot of you gumps don’t know your peoples history tho
HTXBreh
Superstar
1A: Vince Young 1B:Deshaun Watson
I've always said it's either Cam or Jameis.
I don't think anyone thought Bama was invincible the 2nd time around. The 1st time yeah, but Clemson was already loading up by the time Watson actually beat them. Watson was a great college QB but I wouldn't consider him the best, he wasn't as talented as Cam nor as dominant, and he took more losses than both Cam and Jameis combined.
I think you go Cam for dominance and Jameis if you place value in that he had 2 great years instead of just one. Both won Heismans and Watson didn't.
Honorable mention to Lamar Jackson because he put up videogame numbers on a team that wasn't shyt and made them look like a squad. Lamar Jackson on a team like Clemson is probably greatest college QB to ever play the game.
