He's fantastic
But man... there's still so many plays where he doesn't even have to read the defense because kelce and hill get so open... he can afford to play off script so much
I've seen you play this card before: backhanded-compliment analysis, where you're trying to shield yourself from being called a hater. I've noticed
@BucciMane does it too. I guess it's just coincidental that both of y'all just happen to be Patriots fans, right?
You bring up all these caveats that I highly doubt you do for any other QB, as if he's the only QB who benefits from conditions that allow them to exist as they are. This season you constantly talked about how defenses aren't bailing him out anymore by dropping interceptions, and then in the next breath, you claim that opposition teams are "too stupid" when he does end up winning. Or you as you're doing here, you claim he doesn't even need to read the defense because his wide-outs are "so open". You find reasons not to give him his deserved credit. You view his play through a lens that doesn't match up with what's happening in reality.
He's played off the script well before he even came into the league; he made the improbable happen before he even came into the league. The ability to extend plays by any means necessary, the mentality to take any and every risk no matter the situation, and the skill to contort his arm with the combination of touch and power to find players that 99.999999999% of QBs in NFL history wouldn't -- even in their wildest dreams. Kelce and Tyreek are the beneficiaries of that. Now, that's not to say that either of them aren't great players in their own right (arguably the best at their respective positions), but the
magic doesn't exist without him.