He has wins over PRIME versions of Margarito, Lara, Martinez, Cintron, Wright, Philips, Mitchell. You have to remember, Mayweather chose not to face Williams when he was the
#1 rated mandatory challenger. Once that happened, Williams moved up in order to get better fights. His issue was he was largely avoided in the 3 weight classes he was actively fighting in-147, 154, 160. I believe his height, offensive output, and reach would have been enough to beat Mayweather.
Margarito a B class at best fighter, the fight could have went either way, plus like in real life people only remember the end of a fight, Marg winning 5 of the last 6 rounds was the dominant statement of that fight, and showed that the lowly one dimensional AM had more levels and adjusted and broke his will before time failed him
Lara, the gifts of gifts, nikkas called for Williams retirement after this fight........
Mitchell already shot and completely done by the time Floyd finished with him, it may be argued he was shot before Floyd ko'ed him
Philips, Verno, seriously who the fukk is that bum, you really mention a nikka with 11 L's
Crispy Creme Winky the fat un primed version, and still Winky with his slapping ass was countering beautifully and knocking Williams across the ring, even buzzing him at times, before fat boy got tired
Martinez another Bum ass hype job, who never had no intentions of avenging his brutal L to and Margarito and hid in a weak ass 160 division fighting bums, and still I felt he boxed the shyt out of P dubb and should have got th clear UD, he won 7 rounds in the first match IMO
Williams is a good little fight just short of elite, his size and length protected him from his amateurish skills, at the bigger weights when he was fighting taller people his sized the problems arose