Should Kasich challenge Trump in a primary for 2020?

  • Yes, Split the Vote (/no twism)....

  • No, Buckeye Salute (Smitty release them wolves on him)...

  • Trump is winning reelection regardless...


Results are only viewable after voting.

smitty22

Is now part of Thee Alliance. Ill die for this ish
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
63,568
Reputation
31,502
Daps
214,691
Yep and it doesn't help that statehouse has been and will continue to be utter trash. For all the shyt we can give Kasich, let's not forget that he fought against his own party for Medicaid expansion. I don't see DeWine doing anything like that, he pretty much ran as a sycophant.
Facts, good luck with law school breh
 

Professor Emeritus

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
51,330
Reputation
19,656
Daps
203,823
Reppin
the ether
Ya'all are assuming that Kaisch will split the vote in a way that helps the Democrats. I'm not so certain about that.

Damn near everyone on the right who would ever dream of voting for Trump is gonna vote for Trump. His voting base is set.

But there's a whole "Never Trump" right wing contingent too. Whoever runs for the Dems is going to get some votes from right-wingers who just can't imagine voting for Trump.

What if Kaisch runs? Then those right-wingers actually have an option other than the Dem. He won't take many votes either way, but there's a chance he could take MORE votes from the Democratic candidate than he takes from Trump, just from the "Never Trumpers" who are looking for some way out.


I don't think anyone on the right affects Trump's candidacy unless they are extremely popular, or they make REALLY strong arguments against him in the primary that are then mimicked by the Democrat in the general, only they hold more weight because "even the republicans" have said it.




(edit: That's why it was REALLY stupid for the Dems to run Hillary in 2016. She was the only candidate so hated that even people who hated Trump and didn't want him to win still sat out the election rather than admit to themselves that they had voted for her.)
 

Baka's Weird Case

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jul 25, 2015
Messages
15,791
Reputation
6,861
Daps
77,181
Reppin
Goon Squad - Catset
Ya'all are assuming that Kaisch will split the vote in a way that helps the Democrats. I'm not so certain about that.

Damn near everyone on the right who would ever dream of voting for Trump is gonna vote for Trump. His voting base is set.

But there's a whole "Never Trump" right wing contingent too. Whoever runs for the Dems is going to get some votes from right-wingers who just can't imagine voting for Trump.

What if Kaisch runs? Then those right-wingers actually have an option other than the Dem. He won't take many votes either way, but there's a chance he could take MORE votes from the Democratic candidate than he takes from Trump, just from the "Never Trumpers" who are looking for some way out.


I don't think anyone on the right affects Trump's candidacy unless they are extremely popular, or they make REALLY strong arguments against him in the primary that are then mimicked by the Democrat in the general, only they hold more weight because "even the republicans" have said it.




(edit: That's why it was REALLY stupid for the Dems to run Hillary in 2016. She was the only candidate so hated that even people who hated Trump and didn't want him to win still sat out the election rather than admit to themselves that they had voted for her.)
thats why im saying he should challenge in a primary, not a general election. i think any candidate other than trump is going to split more votes from the dem than him
 
Last edited:

Slim

Superstar
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
4,405
Reputation
875
Daps
21,180
Reppin
Valley of the SUNS
Man, one of the highlights of following the 2016 Election on here was watching @smitty22 drag Kasich relentlessly.

Kasich name was like a bat-signal and anyone who uttered the slightest compliment about him got negged by smitty. :russ:

Anyway, as has been mentioned, Trump approval is sky high with Republicans. This would be wasted effort by any Republican.
 

Baka's Weird Case

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jul 25, 2015
Messages
15,791
Reputation
6,861
Daps
77,181
Reppin
Goon Squad - Catset
Man, one of the highlights of following the 2016 Election on here was watching @smitty22 drag Kasich relentlessly.

Kasich name was like a bat-signal and anyone who uttered the slightest compliment about him got negged by smitty. :russ:

Anyway, as has been mentioned, Trump approval is sky high with Republicans. This would be wasted effort by any Republican.
as it should be :conway:
he gutted their education system. just cause he isnt rude in debates like trump doesnt mean he should get any kind of pass
 

the cac mamba

Veteran
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
100,625
Reputation
13,401
Daps
294,743
Reppin
NULL
you know whats a crazy scenario? unlikely, but i think it happened to obama

what if trump wins the 2020 election....but the senate goes democrat? :dead: he'd be putting his fukkin papers in on jan 21st
 

acri1

The Chosen 1
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
23,852
Reputation
3,745
Daps
104,211
Reppin
Detroit
you know whats a crazy scenario? unlikely, but i think it happened to obama

what if trump wins the 2020 election....but the senate goes democrat? :dead: he'd be putting his fukkin papers in on jan 21st

At that point Trump might say "fukk it" and go facist and block everything that gets to his desk, and just use executive orders to do what he wants.

Even with a majority it's hard to imagine Dems getting enough Rethugs onboard to actually impeach him.
 

Serious

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
79,846
Reputation
14,192
Daps
189,986
Reppin
1st Round Playoff Exits
Ya'all are assuming that Kaisch will split the vote in a way that helps the Democrats. I'm not so certain about that.

Damn near everyone on the right who would ever dream of voting for Trump is gonna vote for Trump. His voting base is set.

But there's a whole "Never Trump" right wing contingent too. Whoever runs for the Dems is going to get some votes from right-wingers who just can't imagine voting for Trump.

What if Kaisch runs? Then those right-wingers actually have an option other than the Dem. He won't take many votes either way, but there's a chance he could take MORE votes from the Democratic candidate than he takes from Trump, just from the "Never Trumpers" who are looking for some way out.


I don't think anyone on the right affects Trump's candidacy unless they are extremely popular, or they make REALLY strong arguments against him in the primary that are then mimicked by the Democrat in the general, only they hold more weight because "even the republicans" have said it.




(edit: That's why it was REALLY stupid for the Dems to run Hillary in 2016. She was the only candidate so hated that even people who hated Trump and didn't want him to win still sat out the election rather than admit to themselves that they had voted for her.)
Great perspective....
 

the cac mamba

Veteran
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
100,625
Reputation
13,401
Daps
294,743
Reppin
NULL
Ya'all are assuming that Kaisch will split the vote in a way that helps the Democrats. I'm not so certain about that.

Damn near everyone on the right who would ever dream of voting for Trump is gonna vote for Trump. His voting base is set.

But there's a whole "Never Trump" right wing contingent too. Whoever runs for the Dems is going to get some votes from right-wingers who just can't imagine voting for Trump.

What if Kaisch runs? Then those right-wingers actually have an option other than the Dem. He won't take many votes either way, but there's a chance he could take MORE votes from the Democratic candidate than he takes from Trump, just from the "Never Trumpers" who are looking for some way out.


I don't think anyone on the right affects Trump's candidacy unless they are extremely popular, or they make REALLY strong arguments against him in the primary that are then mimicked by the Democrat in the general, only they hold more weight because "even the republicans" have said it.




(edit: That's why it was REALLY stupid for the Dems to run Hillary in 2016. She was the only candidate so hated that even people who hated Trump and didn't want him to win still sat out the election rather than admit to themselves that they had voted for her.)
but kasich wouldnt run as a third party, right? he'd be primary or bust

running as a third party loser would tarnish him forever with no chance of winning, i dont see him doing that
 

Uncle Phil 36

All Star
Joined
Feb 24, 2014
Messages
4,926
Reputation
680
Daps
11,309
but kasich wouldnt run as a third party, right? he'd be primary or bust

running as a third party loser would tarnish him forever with no chance of winning, i dont see him doing that

Man if he ran as third party, it would be simply to screw over Trump. Doe he dislike him that much?

He can say goodbye to a lot of people and opportunities lol.

He might be able to siphon away enough votes to give Trump no chance to win with him in it
 

wtfyomom

All Star
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
7,700
Reputation
-757
Daps
11,435
Reppin
NULL
tenor.gif


@smitty22

The elephant in the room is that Trump is the greatest Republican POTUS since Reagan and a hypothetical primary challenge won't hurt him.

Also, consider...
  • Fox News propaganda would inoculate Republicans from whatever Kasich tried to pull.
  • People who think the borders and immigration are not going to vote for Democrats.
  • Trump is delivering on the culture wars that these fascists are overly invested in.
  • Corporate donors are getting everything they wanted and more with the Trump regime.
  • Trump generates turnout and activates white identity politics in ways no other Republican can.
  • Republicans will vote for their party before ceding power to Democrats.
If you want to beat Trump, then build on what was accomplished in Kansas, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Michigan in 2018. If you want to end Republicanism, then don't squander the enthusiasm that Abrams, Gillum, and O'Rourke generated in their respective states.

There's no need for this on a wing and a prayer stuff, the electoral map is clear.
how are we quantifying greatest ? cause George Bush Sr , not saying he was good but >>>>>>>>>Trump. Trump is either the worst or 2nd worst president ever, toss up with W
 

NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
46,320
Reputation
5,850
Daps
93,964
Reppin
Uncertain grounds
how are we quantifying greatest ? cause George Bush Sr , not saying he was good but >>>>>>>>>Trump. Trump is either the worst or 2nd worst president ever, toss up with W

W's administration was way worse

I say his administration because cheney ran that shyt

And if kasich goes 3rd party the dem wins automatically
 
Top