I thought he let that dude off easy, he broke into his home, killed his wifes dying gift, trashed his other car and stole his ride, he basically forced the devil out of retirement, for a revenge flick you should be like when he finally gets his hands on dude, like this guy was called the boogeyman for a reason, let him catch the dude, rip his eyelids off and keep taking his picture, then skin him and dump a whole bag of salt on him. Thats the price that little brat should pay for pulling him back into the game.
When he killed his pops was at least he stabbed him and left him to bleed out
The fact that homie had to run for his life, hide, and live in fear for the majority of the movie was torture enough. He wasn't worth shyt and John dispatched him accordingly