Andre was a bigger draw and was fukking awesome in the ring when he could still move. Would love to see his work in the 70's to confirm if his early 80's stuff wasn't an illusion.
Vader had probably a better "catalog" of matches than Taker. But we gotta remember that Taker had to work with worthless bums for most of the first half of his career. He didn't start having really good matches on a consistent basis until 2006.
Undertaker has easily the GOAT gimmick. That shyt shouldn't have lasted more than 7 years and the guy has made it the most respected figure in wrestling. He can still work his ass off and even though he's not that "big" (no Patterson), he works like a bigman so I have no issues with him being mentioned as the greatest ever in that regard
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a8cba/a8cbaa340871025e759967fa275f61ef92d37958" alt="salute :salute: :salute:"