After reading the article, anyone who is defending it needs to reread it.... Its fukking nonsense.
First... her entire premise is wrong. Black men do not see themselves in Kavanaugh. She's confusing and conflating two different lines of thought here:
- One is feeling empathy for the accused (which she believes is what is happening, but its not, because Kavanaugh is not suffering from racial discrimination in this case)
- And the other is feeling mistrust for the system (which black men do feel 100%, regardless of the case).
While these two means of thinking are not always mutually exclusive, they are 100% exclusive in the Kavanaugh case because, as I said above,
Kavanaugh is not black so the racial angle isn't there.
For any black person to miss this is downright baffling to me.
Using Jemele's rationale, the title could have been any of the following
Why black men see themselves in Harvey Weinstien
Why black men see themselves in Brock Turner
Why black men see themselves in Daniel Holtzclaw
etc etc you get my point.
Let me make this as clear as I possibly can...
When black men show empathy to the accused in these cases... we are showing empathy because the accused is usually getting railroaded for racial reasons.
We say to ourselves, "That could have been me, i'm a black man, they wouldn't believe me too because I am black"
Its the same as when we show empathy for a little black boy gunned down for the police.
We say to ourselves. that could have been my brother, my nephew, my son, that could have been me.
We are showing empathy because our race is the defining factor here.
Now if that same cop guns down a white boy, we aren't going to celebrate or anything. Even though its not a black boy, we we still distrust the cop.
However, we dont share that
empathy with the white boy as we do with the black boy for obvious, racial reasons that any black person in America should be able to pick up on.
Kavanaugh is not black, so none of the racial empathy argument even applies to him.
Jemele Hill even goes as far as to say "IF Kavanaugh was black...."
BUT HE'S NOT BLACK, THATS THE POINT!!! We don't see ourselves in him. We an't capping for this cac, but we also dont trust the system either.
If Jemele cant understand the fundamental reasoning of a black man, she should keep black men out of her mouth and write about some shyt she knows about.