Toney’s ideal opponent was an aggressive fighter to came at him and gave him opportunities to counter. For example, Barkley and Jirov. Hopkins was better on his feet, extremely smart, and difficult to hit. He was a better middleweight in his prime IMO and would beat Toney.
Toney would have won when they were both in the same division or a division apart, from 1992-94, assuming he was in shape. Hopkins was still improving.
@patscorpio @Newzz was this fight ever close to happening?
They were scheduled to fight in 2003 at 190 lbs after Toney beat Jirov. Hopkins was supposed to go up a crazy amount, 30 lbs. They had a couple press conferences, then it got canceled. That would have been too much for Hopkins to put on.
Toney, Hopkins Set to Fight?