Its about time: BBC's Sherlock Appreciation thread

[phillycavsfan]

season 2 episode 1

they're not totally alike but if you pay attention and are very observant you can tell that guy ritchie's sherlock holmes films influenced sherlock

They're both taken from the original Sherlock stories from the Arthur Conan Doyle novels. Except the Downey movies are shyt and the TV series is pure piff.

 

[Monoblock]

They're both taken from the original Sherlock stories from the Arthur Conan Doyle novels. Except the Downey movies are shyt and the TV series is pure piff.

Basically. The movies were ok but the TV series is amazing. I hate that the show is on hiatus. Both actors playing Sherlock and Watson are in the Hobbit movies and one of them is the villain in the new Star Trek sequel.

 

[Dirty Mcdrawz]

They're both taken from the original Sherlock stories from the Arthur Conan Doyle novels. Except the Downey movies are shyt and the TV series is pure piff.

Duh, I'm not saying Guy Ritchie's version is the source material, I'm saying that the Guy Ritchie's version and BBC version share similarities outside the source material. You can hear it subtley in the music and visually as well. I love the show and I grew up reading the novels watching the cartoon,and watching Jeremy Brett Sherlock Holmes.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Majestyx]

 

[yseJ]

I liked it, took some time to get used to but I can dig the modern take on things. theres obviously some reaches in a lot of them but it was obvious they wanted to make the show more fast-paced and appealing to the masses than true-to-the-book holmes

robert downey jr sherlock movies aint even sherlock holmes has nothing to do with sherlock holmes, its just an action movie that uses the dudes name

 

[Gilver]

benedict cumberbatch

 

[Danie84]

I thought I was the only one who be watching Masterpiece Theatre on PBS

What y'all no about Rosemary & Thymes?

 

[Lord Piffington]

goat show!!! loved the movies love the show hope we´ll get another season

 

[OG_StankBrefs]

I thought I was the only one who be watching Masterpiece Theatre on PBS

What y'all no about Rosemary & Thymes?

I stay watchin PBS.

Dis Old House.

Kimchi Chronicles.

Simply Ming

 

[phillycavsfan]

I finished the second season last weekend. That finale was . In fact, every episode was great except the Baskerville episode.

Anybody have any theories on what happened to Sherlock? I know

Spoiler

it must have something to do with the lab assistant Molly.

 

[Trojan 24]

I finished the second season last weekend. That finale was . In fact, every episode was great except the Baskerville episode.

Anybody have any theories on what happened to Sherlock? I know

Spoiler

it must have something to do with the lab assistant Molly.

I've read numerous fan theories of what happened. One being everyone at the scene being in the act. They reason that Watson was in such a state of shock that he didn't properly check his vitals. It's , but plausible. But that also brings the question whether it was a dummy that fell, or Holmes somehow landed safely on something. But yea i think Molly had some part in it.


Also the writer of the show stated in an interview that there were clues within the final episode.

 

[KiD WavE]

I had to look this thread up to see if it existed because this show is



4 episodes in and damn

this one of the best shows Ive ever seen

Im gonna have to slow down

 

[yseJ]

when is the next season coming out ?

thats a big problem with british shows. they have so few eppies and the wait is agonizing...

 

[Jermio]

Y'all need to watch Luther too if you haven't. Both shows are

 

[Scustin Bieburr]

I finished the second season last weekend. That finale was . In fact, every episode was great except the Baskerville episode.

Anybody have any theories on what happened to Sherlock? I know

Spoiler

it must have something to do with the lab assistant Molly.

I think its exactly what it looked like.

Spoiler

Maybe he's just going to come back as a ghost.

Its not too crazy of a reach considering that the Author of the books actually believed in fairies, and ghosts and shyt. So it could be a little nod to him.

I can't imagine it being anything else without it seeming dumb as hell to be honest.