Dog Based Gremlin
Veteran
one reason why Starrcade didnt feel big because i dont think they ever went into a Stadium to make it feel bigger than the other ppvsLooking back, most Starrcades werent that good, and I'm a big WCW fan. WCWs prime of 96-98 didnt have any really great Starrcade PPVS imo. Starrcade was probably only better 2 or 3 times. Bischoff has said on his podcast that he really treated Hallowee Havoc like the #1 PPV, and looking back it makes sense. There are like 5 or 6 Halloween Havocs that I consider great PPVs.
Most years when TNA was good, WM was still pretty good even if WWE as a whole wasn't, so there's probably only one or two years where BFG was better also.
They put on big time matches at all their ppvs during the nWo atleast big named star matches.