Is Robert Griffin still a runaway Rookie of the year candidate?

[PHamm]

RG3 is the only rookie that looks like he's already in his prime. There's no way Luck deserves it over him.

 

[Mr swag]

Doug Martin putting in his bed but as we all know QBs are dikkrode in this league.

So we have Andrew Luck who turned his team from the worst team in the league to a possible Wildcard team.

We also have Russell Wilson posting up a 95 QB rating, running the ball very well for a QB, and also possibly making the playoffs.

RGIII is putting up Madden numbers (without the INTs ) and is on the brink of the playoffs depending on this Giants game. But if the Redskins dont make a playoff run, is he still undoubtedly the NFL Rookie of the Year?

Whats the DROY lookin like anyway?

It between rg3 and Martin.


Luck been out weeks ago

 

[ecks12]

This is the best season for rookies that I can remember....it could be the recency effect but there are so many rookies having major impacts.

 

[Swagnificent]

I really can't stand all the racists that are trying to put Luck in the same class as RGIII. RGIII has CLEARLY been the best rookie QB. Only racists would deny it.

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

does a bear shyt in the woods ?

 

[kash10003]

i think RG3 has it as this point, but Luck has the colts going 2-14 last year vs 8-4 so far

 

[Juven]

This is the best season for rookies that I can remember....it could be the recency effect but there are so many rookies having major impacts.

last yrs draft was ass. We went from ponder, gabbert, Locker to Wilson, rg3 and luck

 

[NormanConnors]

i think RG3 has it as this point, but Luck has the colts going 2-14 last year vs 8-4 so far

colts were tanking last year

 

[ECA]

colts were tanking last year

So Curtis Painter was gonna put them in a position to win games?

 

[SHAQAVELLI]

It's gotta be Luck.

 

[THE MACHINE]

last yrs draft was ass. We went from ponder, gabbert, Locker to Wilson, rg3 and luck

Exactly....GMs picked their QBs a year early

 

[mastermind]

Exactly....GMs picked their QBs a year early

I was so happy Shanny didnt fall for the okie doke and take Gabbert or Ponder when they were sitting there.

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

colts were tanking last year

Who exactly was it that was instructing the Colts to tank last year?

Was it their defensive coordinator Larry Coyer? No he got fired.

Was it their offensive coordinator Clyde Christensen? No he lost his job.

Was it their head coach Jim Caldwell? No he got fired.

Was it their GM Chris Polian? No he got fired.

Was it their President Bill Polian? No he got fired.

So who was it? I guess these guys didn't care about their job at all and were willing to get fired to help the Colts get Luck. And what team that's deliberately tanking wins a game in week 16?

The Colts defense was trash for years, and still isn't very good. The Colts o-line was trash for years, and still is. The Colts never had a quality backup because Peyton didn't missed games so they ended up having to start Curtis Painter at QB. Painter shouldn't have even been in the league and is not in the league anymore. That's why they went 2-14.

This argument that the Colts were deliberately losing games is retarded. Just someone who doesn't know anything about the Colts making ignorant statements they can't back up at all. Colts were terrible last year, and improved this year. Get over it.

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

Andrew Luck, 12 games, 4 game winning drives. Would be 5 if colts didn't give up last second TD to Jags.

ROY? Nah. Should Colts fans be worried? Nope.

 

[courtdog]

Who exactly was it that was instructing the Colts to tank last year?

Was it their defensive coordinator Larry Coyer? No he got fired.

Was it their offensive coordinator Clyde Christensen? No he lost his job.

Was it their head coach Jim Caldwell? No he got fired.

Was it their GM Chris Polian? No he got fired.

Was it their President Bill Polian? No he got fired.

So who was it? I guess these guys didn't care about their job at all and were willing to get fired to help the Colts get Luck. And what team that's deliberately tanking wins a game in week 16?

The Colts defense was trash for years, and still isn't very good. The Colts o-line was trash for years, and still is. The Colts never had a quality backup because Peyton didn't missed games so they ended up having to start Curtis Painter at QB. Painter shouldn't have even been in the league and is not in the league anymore. That's why they went 2-14.

This argument that the Colts were deliberately losing games is retarded. Just someone who doesn't know anything about the Colts making ignorant statements they can't back up at all. Colts were terrible last year, and improved this year. Get over it.

You wanna know what's retarded? You
Like the colts couldnt of picked up a free agent QB

Jason Campbell
McNabb
Vince
Matt lienart
Matt Hassellback
Or pretty much anybody besides Painter

John Beck my nikka doe