Is Robert Griffin still a runaway Rookie of the year candidate?

[Ohene]

Doug Martin putting in his bid but as we all know QBs are dikkrode in this league.

So we have Andrew Luck who turned his team from the worst team in the league to a possible Wildcard team.

We also have Russell Wilson posting up a 95 QB rating, running the ball very well for a QB, and also possibly making the playoffs.

RGIII is putting up Madden numbers (without the INTs ) and is on the brink of the playoffs depending on this Giants game. But if the Redskins dont make a playoff run, is he still undoubtedly the NFL Rookie of the Year?

Whats the DROY lookin like anyway?

 

[PTBG]

After the 2 come from behind W's over the Packers and Lions, and its looking like the Colts will make the playoffs too, its looks like it will go to Luck, but personally they both should win it. shyt I think you can say that both Robert and Luck are top 10 QB's on the game already.

 

[MikelArteta]

russell wilson
russel wilson 19 tds 8 ints, 64% seattle 8-4
qb rating of 94

 

[malbaker86]

There's NO wrong choice if you objectively look at it

 

[Stone]

russell wilson
russel wilson 19 tds 8 ints, 64% seattle 8-4
qb rating of 94

Seattle is 7-5

 

[Apathy]

Im just glad we have seen a ton of promising rookies this year.

 

[THE MACHINE]

This is the best season for rookies that I can remember....it could be the recency effect but there are so many rookies having major impacts.

 

[kingofnyc]

they gonna give it to luck
cause we all know WHY










my skin iz my sin

 

[malbaker86]

RG3 HAS BEEN A TOP 5 QB THIS YEAR.
TEAM RECORD SHOULD HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH ROY.

THAT QB IN CINCY GOT TO THE PLAYOFFS AS A ROOKIE LAST SEASON TOO.



​

Why shouldn't team record have NOTHING to do with it?

 

[Brady-Carter]

This years rookie class is piff..

I would lean to RG3, he got the numbers. And the way he protects the ball for a rooking is mind blowing.

Plus I would say the skins have less talent then the colts or bucs.

 

[VladTheImpaler]

russell wilson
russel wilson 19 tds 8 ints, 64% seattle 8-4
qb rating of 94

It's still Seattle though

 

[PTBG]

RG3 has been great too, but I think people forget that he has Morris to hand off to, as both of them are deadly as fukk as a combination. While Luck has no running game what so ever, and Luck literally is doing everything for the Colts on offense, even though having Reggie Wayne as your number 1 option to throw too is not too shabby to have if your a rookie too. Both are great and are the reason why the teams are where they are at currently. Its still early on in there careers, both are going to be top 5 QB's for the next decade too probably.

 

[Reggie]

I think RG3 and Luck will be co rookies of the year.

 

[malbaker86]

RG3 HAS CLEARLY BEEN THE BEST ROOKIE IN THE NFL.
WHY SHOULD HIS CRAPPY TEAMMATES HAVE AN EFFECT ON AN INDIVIDUAL AWARD?


​

And Luck's teammates are great?

It should be co-ROY's but it doesn't really matter or diminish what both qb's have been able to do this season

 

[jfkennedy]

I think it's up to RG3 and Luck, and RG3 will most likely get it if he keeps his INT numbers down.

And I'm throwing in my bid for Janoris Jenkins for DROY, but I'm super biased lol.