Is Deadpool the most comic book accurate potrayal we've seen on tv/film ?

[Uptown WaYo87]

I thought this thread was about comic book accuracy. That would rule out Jackman's Wolverine.

Yea it is

As a huge wolverine fan, jackman being over 6ft always bothered me. Wolverine is supposed to be a little ball of fury. Hugh jackman got his personality down but the tall shyt always threw me off. Its equivelant to casting a skinny superman to me

I love sir patric stewart as professor x but i felt he was a bit too old. They need someone in their late 30s,40s. Sir patric wouldnt be able to run around the savage land he look like he belong in a wheelchair. But he nailed the prof x role, personality wise

Deadpool has an accurate physical apperance and accurate personality. You can switch from deadpool movies to the comic and it still feels like its the same person

 

[Marks]

Mickey Rourke as Marv

I don't hate the sequel as much as some but I still wish we got just a straight adaptation of "Hell and Back." Probably my favorite Sin City tale. IIRC they wanted to do it/there were rumors they wanted Depp as Wallace too.
Hell and Back (comics) - Wikipedia

 

[8WON6]

i think Professor X by far is the best casting.

and i know people will hate this, but I never really liked hugh jackman as wolverine. He just doesn't fit what i pictured from the comic or the cartoon. Hugh has done an aight job with the character, but i would have kept looking.

 

[OmegaK2099]

I don't hate the sequel as much as some but I still wish we got just a straight adaptation of "Hell and Back." Probably my favorite Sin City tale. IIRC they wanted to do it/there were rumors they wanted Depp as Wallace too.
Hell and Back (comics) - Wikipedia

Same. I mean it's still Rodriguez

I'm content they adapted That Yellow b*stard to a T as well

 

[OmegaK2099]

Benedict Cumberbatch as Strange

And Chris Evans as Cap I thought was spot on as well

 

[parallax]

Perfect casting, incorrectly written. Nightcrawler is a monk, the brother of rogue and son of mystique and hates violence.

yeah, i get some details that would be hard to produce for the movies like his fine fur, but making him an introverted monk kinda goes against most of what people love about him.

 

[MajesticLion]

Absolutely not

 

[verbalkint]

Way too many posts in before this mentioned.

 

[nieman]

#1 is Christopher Reeve as Superman - He embodied damn near 60 years of Supes. Even in the shytty III and Quest for Peace, Reeve was on his A game
#2 - Chiklis & Evan as Thing & Torch. They had it perfectly, even down to their chemistry.
#3 - RDJ as Tony Stark/Iron Man. The gripe is that he's too smart...he's perhaps the best engineer in the 616, but he's not Reed - as they had him portrayed. Hell, they nerfed everyone else....they should've nerfed his intelligence. But I do like how they used the PTSD and paranoia as a stand in for the Demon in the Bottle
#4 - Bill Bixby as Banner. He played the nomadic genius that just wants t b left alone, perfectly.

 

[richaveli83]

Christopher Reeves as Superman
Chris Evans as Captain America
Kelsey Grammer as Beast

 

[Geek Nasty]

When they remake X Men, I think Bruce Willis would be a dope professor X.

Bruce Willis doesn't act anymore. I mean he's in movies, but he doesn't act anymore.

 

[TripleAgent]

To answer the actual question asked by the OP, Sin City is the answer, Deadpool is number 2.

 

[Hoodoo Child]

Shaq as Steel

 

[Deltron]

from my limited comic knowledge, I'd say Fury since I remember learning about how they modeled him after Sam L when they relaunched, so only naturally he's Fury in the MCU.


also heard lots of downy should be stark way before 2008, cause downy's real life mirrored that of starks in the comics

 

[CouldBeWorse]

Some would say faithful to a fault.