If Peyton becomes the 1st Starting Qb to win Rings with 2 Diff Teams is he the Goat?

[PHamm]

How can Brady be out when he has a shot at 4 or 5 rings. Losing in the SB is a better season than losing in the championship games, no?

2 things:

Brady has never won a superbowl in the non-spygate era.

He's lost to the same QB twice in the last 2 SBs he's played in, and both times his team was better.

Tom Brady has not played GREAT in a playoff game since 2007.

Brady can still win the best QB of his generation argument though. Peyton will be hard pressed to even do that.

 

[THE MACHINE]

2 things:

Brady has never won a superbowl in the non-spygate era.

He's lost to the same QB twice in the last 2 SBs he's played in, and both times his team was better.

Tom Brady has not played GREAT in a playoff game since 2007.

Brady can still win the best QB of his generation argument though. Peyton will be hard pressed to even do that.

They haven't been chopped liver since 2004 friend, they went 18-1 in 2007 and have 2 appearances

Brady played 3 games in 2011 with 878 yards, 67% 9 tds, 4 turnovers with 100 QB rating.

I understand if you roll with Montana though, he's #2 to me

 

[yseJ]

49ers defensive rank '79-'92(points based might I add)
'79=27
26
2
23
4
1
2
3
3
8
3
2
4
'92=3

So only 4 out of 14 years was the defense ranked outside the top 4 in points allowed

Montana is the man but Brady is the goat

how about patriots defensive ranking in the brady years ?

4
9
15
8
5
6
4
2
17
2
1
17
6

the bowls pats won were with #1, #6 and #2 ranked defenses

its not rocket science, defenses win championships. I dont really see what point youre trying to make here

 

[PHamm]

They haven't been chopped liver since 2004 friend, they went 18-1 in 2007 and have 2 appearances

Brady played 3 games in 2011 with 878 yards, 67% 9 tds, 4 turnovers with 100 QB rating.

I understand if you roll with Montana though, he's #2 to me

Montana is clearly #1.

I never saw Unitas play nor will I pretend like I know about his career but from what other people say, I think he has to be in consideration for #2.

 

[THE MACHINE]

@yseJ The point is everyone points out the Pats defense like the 9ers did what the Saints did. They had dominant defenses so we shouldn't use the Pats D as some sort of asterisk against Tom while we act like Montana carried the load on his own.

 

[THE MACHINE]

Montana is clearly #1.

I never saw Unitas play nor will I pretend like I know about his career but from what other people say, I think he has to be in consideration for #2.

I respect your #1 pick but I just can't understand how it's "clearly"

 

[IAmGettingAMailOrderBride]

I thought one of the guys from the undefeated dolphins went to another team and won, I think his name was bob greise

EDIt: It was Earl Morrall, he was on the undefeated dolphins with bob griese

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earl_Morrall

 

[yseJ]

They had dominant defenses so we shouldn't use the Pats D as some sort of asterisk against Tom while we act like Montana carried the load on his own.

who exactly is using it as asterisk while acting "like Montana carried the load on his own" ?

 

[THE MACHINE]

who exactly is using it as asterisk while acting "like Montana carried the load on his own" ?

See post #17

 

[Jesus Shuttlesworth]

Yup. That and all the other shyt.

 

[Jesus Shuttlesworth]

PLUS

plus

Funny thing about Brady is he hasn't won shyt since he's actually become an elite QB.

 

[Tom Shady]

PLUS

plus

does peyton's team switch out defenses when they get to the playoffs? all these great regular seasons but when they lose in the 1st round all of a sudden it's the defenses fault.

 

[Rekkapryde]

does peyton's team switch out defenses when they get to the playoffs? all these great regular seasons but when they lose in the 1st round all of a sudden it's the defenses fault.

No one said Peyton isn't at fault, but the Pats defense was the strength of those SB teams.

 

[PHamm]

I respect your #1 pick but I just can't understand how it's "clearly"

pull up Montana's playoff stays/records. All that needs to be said

 

[Brady-Carter]

2 things:


Tom Brady has not played GREAT in a playoff game since 2007.

So the Texans game last year, and the Broncos the year before did not happen. Or you just talking out your ass and trying to prove that your opinion should not be taken seriously..