If Peyton becomes the 1st Starting Qb to win Rings with 2 Diff Teams is he the Goat?

[BigE214]

3rd best bruh

 

[Rekkapryde]

Brady is still GOAT followed closely by Montana

PLUS

plus

 

[THE MACHINE]

PLUS

plus

Who is your pick, friend

 

[Jplaya2023]

Who is your pick, friend

obvoiusly joe montana. Brady is top 10 though

 

[PremierDaTruth]

He has to make it out of the first round 1st

 

[bl2k8]

Would Warner have been the GOAT if he won in 09

 

[Formerly known as...]

Montana is goat fukk what manning does from here on out.

But Manning is very fukking dope!

 

[THE MACHINE]

obvoiusly joe montana. Brady is top 10 though

Are you two the same person?

Either way, he gives credit to a kicker and a defense. Now let's compare some weapons from Montana's team to the Patriots shall we:

Roger Craig
Dwight Clark
Jerry Rice = arguably GOAT football player
Ronnie Lott
Haley

49ers defensive rank '79-'92(points based might I add)
'79=27
26
2
23
4
1
2
3
3
8
3
2
4
'92=3

So only 4 out of 14 years was the defense ranked outside the top 4 in points allowed

Montana is the man but Brady is the goat

 

[Jplaya2023]

Are you two the same person?

Either way, he gives credit to a kicker and a defense. Now let's compare some weapons from Montana's team to the Patriots shall we:

Roger Craig
Dwight Clark
Jerry Rice = arguably GOAT football player
Ronnie Lott
Haley

49ers defensive rank '79-'92(points based might I add)
'79=27
26
2
23
4
1
2
3
3
8
3
2
4
'92=3

So only 4 out of 14 years was the defense ranked outside the top 4 in points allowed

Montana is the man but Brady is the goat

Joe Montana won 2 SB MVPs when jerry rice was in highschool and college

argument over.

 

[Rekkapryde]

obvoiusly joe montana. Brady is top 10 though

 

[Rekkapryde]

Joe Montana won 2 SB MVPs when jerry rice was in highschool and college

argument over.

mufukkaz always talk that shyt until you hit em with that fact. Then it's .....

 

[THE MACHINE]

Joe Montana won 2 SB MVPs when jerry rice was in highschool and college

argument over.

Really? It's over? Because Brady won 3 without a HOF offensive player

 

[PHamm]

the ship sailed a LONG time ago on whether Peyton has a claim to the GOAT QB title. Brady officially made the list after his second loss to Eli. Only guy that has a shot of being the GOAT out of the current QBs is Arod.

 

[PHamm]

Brady is still GOAT followed closely by Montana

 

[THE MACHINE]

the ship sailed a LONG time ago on whether Peyton has a claim to the GOAT QB title. Brady officially made the list after his second loss to Eli. Only guy that has a shot of being the GOAT out of the current QBs is Arod.

How can Brady be out when he has a shot at 4 or 5 rings. Losing in the SB is a better season than losing in the championship games, no?