Thurman is a bad choice for several reasons:
1. He's unproven. He has yet to fight top competition at 147, so we don't know whether he's truly elite or not. He hasn't earned it like Maidana did. He needs more notches on his belt.
2. He isn't a big name yet. The PPV numbers would be terrible because Thurman's name hasn't been built up enough.
3. Is a he a true threat? This one is less important, bc who can truly pose a threat to Floyd, but Thurman isn't even the closest thing to a threat.
Because of 1 and 2, Floyd has no good reason to take the fight. It won't help his legacy and it won't get people to buy the ppv. Not enough incentive for Floyd, Haymon, GB, or Showtime.
I also think it's unfair to Thurman because he's just not ready. But hopefully Schaefer and Haymon will fix that by throwing Thurman in with Khan, Porter, Guerrero, or names like that soon enough.
There's always next year for Thurman if he can win 1 or 2 big fights before then.
Here's my current list for Floyd opponents for next year based on the criteria above:
1. Shawn Porter if he beats Kell Brook up.
2. Lara if he beats Canelo
3. Winner of Cotto/Martinez, so Floyd can be the lineal champ in 3 weight classes at the same damn time.
4. Danny Garcia if he has a good debut at 147.
This is probably what the Actual list for September looks like:
1. Garcia in his 147 debut
2. Khan if he turns his back on Islam.
3. Maidana again
4.Shawn Porter
5. Thurman