how does sin city hold up to you 11 years later?

[Reggie]

Great when it came out and just as good now.

 

[David_TheMan]

Saw it when it came out, thought it was poor movie in terms of acting and story, outside of mickey Rourke.
Saw the 2nd on tv the other day, turned it off after a few minutes, equally terrible.

 

[Bryan Danielson]

Still holds up well and even after 16 years

 

[Detroit Wave]

This shyt was overrated then and now

 

[OmegaK2099]

It's still a good movie, you can tell some of these actors are just having fun working on the movie . Only reason people say it doesn't hold up is because they look at the percieved toxic masculinity, harsh language and depiction of women.

 

[curz]

Classic, one of the best comic adaptions. Pt 2 was ass tho