It wasn’t just the live instruments. RZA was having them record on a certain type of beat then he’d COMPLETELY switch it up so when they heard it the finished version they were like “THE fukk!?!”
RZA’s a genius but I think he might’ve overthought SOME of the production on 8 Diagrams. Like the OG version of The Heart Gently Weeps is MILES better than the album version. That shyt broke my fukking heart when I heard how stripped and soulless the album version was because i’d been bumping the leaked version for weeks beforehand
na. The real heart gently weeps is way better than the dead sample version. Ghosts version is the best but the sample demo was always just a demo and was always gon be rerecorded. shyt had zero rhythym at all and was just loops setup to get there verses. Nothing added to it, Was always a demo and just that.
People even confuse the 2 on yt, theres one labled the og with thousands of comments “this is so much better than album version” and … was the album version exactly. Seems most cant tell the difference but are repeating things theyve seen others say (not saying you did that, just people on yt/wu corp who obviously are confused which version is which)
But he did overproduce on that album. The og thug world and wolves are way better. Wolves i understand it was a sample thing. But thug world changing into unpredictable with that hook and guitar was disgusting. The beat change was dope on rzas but the guitar and dexter wiggles… trash. Also zero reason odbs tribute needed 8 hooks when the mcs literally rhyme in 2s off each other (rae/meth, mk/gza, deck/ugod, rza) and then add 2 minute chinese poem after it.
Besides that, starter and get out the way pa being mediocre, rest of the album was dope to me and imo rzas last real produced album. I saw someone else say the album was literally rzas giving a piece of all his old sounds, + some new stuff and i agree.
Still, 8d might be my 3rd fav wu album. It and the w spar for 3rd. The w retail is better but og 8d > retail. Og the w tho? Might be diff story. But thats the story of every wu album post forever from heavy mental to bpw to pretty toney etc