The with makeup vs without makeup thing is why I always dated women who were very low maintenance with the makeup. Most of the women I dated never even wore foundation...just lip gloss/lipstick. They would do the manicure/pedicure/eye brow stuff but not the clown face thing. At most, maybe alittle concealer for very special events but it wasn't like they went from pepperoni face to smooth. They were already 95% smooth and just went to 100% smooth.
I'm very wary of women who wear makeup because because then you can have a "My Boyfriend Doesn't Think I'm Attractive Without Makeup" thread going on.
Peace