In January 1997, about a half year into the investigation, Idaho Falls officials questioned 20-year-old Chris Tapp, initially for information regarding other suspects.
[4] After over 100 hours of intense police interrogation,
[6] Tapp confessed to the crime under heavy pressure, although no physical evidence tied him to the scene and his confessions were inconsistent and contradictory. Tapp was convicted in May 1998 for aiding and abetting Dodge's rape and murder, and sentenced to a minimum of 30 years in prison.
[7]
In 2001, Tapp recanted his confession and claimed he was coerced by police and fed information about the crime.
[5] In 2007, after Tapp had served ten years in prison, his case was revisited by the
Idaho Innocence Project.
[4] A professor and undergraduate at
Boise State University who worked with the project reviewed Tapp's interrogation tapes and arrived at the conclusion that Tapp had been heavily coerced into his confession.
[8] Tapp's case was appealed in 2017 and the rape charge was rescinded, lessening his sentence from 30 years to 20 years. Tapp had by then served his full 20-year sentence and was released.
[8]
Chris Tapp was exonerated for the murder charge in July 2019, after Brian Leigh Dripps Sr. was arrested as a suspect for Dodge's murder.
[5]
In October 2020, Tapp sued the city of
Idaho Falls for wrongful conviction.
[9] In June 2022, a settlement was reached for $11.4 million.
[10]