Sounds about right. He's in the upper part of the right age spread for her - from what we know about her dating history. ADR seems like he's tight with the crew from the UK, too. Drew Galloway was the best man at his wedding. He's been spotted at soccer matches with Sheamus and Barrett. Paige played soccer in high school, so there's a common interest.
There's still less of an age gap between them than there is between her parents, so they really can't be too mad about this. Not that I expect it to get serious. I cannot imagine Paige will be about that stepmom life.