7.5/10 for me. I think they tried to fit too much into the movie. And there wasn't enough Sherlockness in it for me. They had a few of those "How did they possibly know that" type of moments where they show how smart they are by deducing something, but rarely did it lead to anything too interesting. It was more or less just there because that's what they do. But I like MBB and Cavil and it held my interest for 2 hours. So it gets a passing grade overall.