1/31
@BenjaminDEKR
I resigned from xAI tonight.
It makes me very sad, but was the right thing to do -- and here's why.
xAI told me I either had to delete the post quoted below, or face being fired.
After reviewing everything and thinking a lot, I've decided that I'm not going to delete the post -- which is very clearly a harmless personal opinion.
Why did they tell me to remove this opinion? Well, according to them, the reason is that I acknowledged that Grok 3... exists.
I wish I was joking. I'm not. That's the reason -- the fact that I wrote "Grok 3 (TBD)" is grounds for being fired.
But wait, hasn't Grok 3 been officially acknowledged by xAI? Yes. Yes it has.
I'll post below the official xAI blog post talking about Grok 3, along with many public Elon posts and video where it is repeatedly acknowledged.
To be clear, the post they wanted me to remove is 100% just my personal opinion. I do not know where Grok 3 will stack up against other SOTA models. Hopefully it does well, I don't know. That's why it says "opinion" and "to be determined."
It will probably be pretty good at some things and imperfect at others. I didn't think this was a particularly wild opinion.
Again, their official demand said that even writing "Grok 3 - TBD" is somehow "confidential information." This is absolutely absurd, since it's repeatedly been acknowledged by the company and its famous CEO.
Are they mad that my clearly-labeled opinion didn't guess that the still-unreleased Grok 3 will be higher? Maybe. Probably. Again, maybe it is at the top, I genuinely don't know. That's why it says "to be determined."
The specific feature of Grok I spent the majority of my time working on with a really hard-working team is very cool and I hope it works extremely well for everyone. I won't say what it is because that would be **actual** confidential information. (Maybe after it comes out.)
I still hope Elon and xAI win. Yet......
It's very disappointing to me that a company and leaders who supposedly champion free speech and openness would try to fire a low-level employee over a clearly-labeled opinion that contains absolutely nothing controversial, but here we are.
The entire situation has been very strange. I thought about just deleting the damn thing.... But you know, once you start caving and giving up holding mild personal opinions, the slope becomes very slippery.
I'll keep my speech and dignity and get another job, or build one. Catch ya on the flip side.
[Quoted tweet]
The ranking currently (my opinion), for code:
ChatGPT o1-pro
o1
o3-mini
(all kind of tied)
Grok 3 (expected, tbd)
Claude 3.5 Sonnet
DeepSeek
GPT-4o
Grok 2
Gemini 2.0 Pro Series (might be higher, will probably move up)
2/31
@BenjaminDEKR
3/31
@BenjaminDEKR
4/31
@elonmusk
That’s weird
5/31
@BenjaminDEKR
Pretty weird
6/31
@burkov
From reading your original post, it's clear what's wrong with it. You work on Grok, as you say, and you already put the product, which isn't yet released, below its competitors. They don't tell you that this way likely because saying that you disclosed confidential information would be a legally stronger reason to fire you, but the real reason is PR. No business owner wants their employees to publicly talk about their product as inferior, and not just in the current version, but in the version TBD.
7/31
@BenjaminDEKR
In your scenario they lied to me about the reason instead of just being direct + truthful
If so, that's why I resigned.
8/31
@CreatedByJannn
you literally ranked Grok 3 alongside competitors and it is not even released. Huge red flag for an internal team member to be posting something like that.
and they even offered you to delete the tweet, how on earth do you think you are in the right?
9/31
@BenjaminDEKR
TBD
10/31
@BenjaminDEKR
Grok 3 Official acknowledgement on xAI Blog
11/31
@BasedBeffJezos
I think it's the fact that you leaked expected benchmarks with the ordering.
12/31
@BenjaminDEKR
- That's not the reason they gave me, and also
- these are not benchmarks these are my random opinions / wild guess
that's why I labeled it "opinion" and "TBD"
13/31
@BorisMPower
Surely expressing an opinion on the performance of an unreleased model which you only had access to through working at xAI is against company policies (?)
14/31
@BenjaminDEKR
This was my random opinion of guess not based on any data, which they know. (Because they know what project I was on or wasn't on.)
Also, it was repeatedly (in writing) told to me that it was saying "Grok 3 - TBD" that was the issue. Literally acknowledging that Grok 3 exists.
15/31
@Andercot
Here's what o1 pro had to say about this
16/31
@BenjaminDEKR
Oh I didn't say they didn't have the RIGHT to do it
I said it was absurd and ridiculous and I resigned.
17/31
@StephenPiment
FWIW, Apple has rules just as strict as this for employees, and they enforce them. Doesn’t matter if you think they make sense; they will fire you for violation.
So not just an xAI thing.
18/31
@BenjaminDEKR
Okay, I don't want to work for Apple
19/31
@rajuvamsi007
You are an employee and should do what your employer asks - as long as it's not illegal to do.
This is nothing to do with free speech.
20/31
@BenjaminDEKR
Well they're not my employer anymore so problem solved.
21/31
@fareesh
you posted something that others could easily misunderstand to be a benchmark of an unreleased model
22/31
@BenjaminDEKR
(My opinion) is not a benchmark
23/31
@johnwlockwoodiv
You work there dude. It doesn’t matter if you if you actually have any data or info on it, we presume you do have some insider knowledge for which you used to come to your opinion and now you are setting an expectation with the public.
24/31
@yardtex
Any rookie developer would not reveal information like you did. I would not hire you in my team either. You may want to change careers and do something else.
25/31
@Deb8822
Difference is that Elon's choice of when and how to tease his company's product is his to make, not an employees. Basic stuff really.
26/31
@ovidbme
I really hope you see how you are lying to yourself. It’s super obvious as to why. Not saying I would have done the same but I wouldn’t be very pleased to your ranking of an unreleased product..
27/31
@3percentT
Well, you're
28/31
@wordsandmotions
Your OP ranks your employer's yet-to-be-released product, which you're directly working on, below a competitor's.
It screams saboteur, my friend. All the best in your future endeavors (likely your own business cos your writeup is a red flag).
29/31
@GrippoSkier
Honestly, this is standard practice for corporations now. You cannot post information about your business vs competitors with any insider information, even if it is a ‘personal statement’
That personal statement is using inside information that the public does not have and you most likely violated your employment contract trade secrets, IP, or business intelligence clause.
They have specific departments for managing public relations on new products.
Example:
Everyone know car company F has a new car coming, can every person who works at company F start posting how they think it will stack up to company T or G? That hurts their advertising and it violates the employment contract. Maybe their info is wrong and it gives the illusion that the product is closer and not as good than it really is.
30/31
@Atlbeachchick
31/31
@AtomicNavar33
I actually wonder if this was outright malicious. He was about to get fired anyway or had a political axe to grind.
To post tweets in this format, more info here: https://www.thecoli.com/threads/tips-and-tricks-for-posting-the-coli-megathread.984734/post-52211196