Dude ethers Islam...epic rant

Type Username Here

Not a new member
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
16,368
Reputation
2,385
Daps
32,641
Reppin
humans
Apparently everybody in this thread knew who dude was except me. I just stumbled upon this video on a website where it was linked.

It's okay friend. All issues aside, no one here thinks you're advocating any of his policies. You just liked his points. Now you're educated about the man.

Only the jihadists don't believe you.
 

Robbie3000

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
29,367
Reputation
5,139
Daps
129,453
Reppin
NULL
Apparently everybody in this thread knew who dude was except me. I just stumbled upon this video on a website where it was linked.

Yeah he used to be decent but, he got progressively more right wing in his positions over the past couple of years.
 
Joined
Jul 25, 2012
Messages
1,417
Reputation
-155
Daps
811
Reppin
NULL
I don't think most reasonable critics of Israel here or elsewhere, would agree with that, though they would disagree with the specific applicability of that statement, but saying that the every single movement or organization that is interested in Palestinian issues is a sham and cover for a giant antisemitic Muslim conspiracy to crush Israel and establish a Middle Eastern caliphate (as Condell claims) is definitely a way to lose credibility.

There is a far leap between "interested in Palestinian issues" and "anti-Zionism."

Also, you're obviously misrepresenting his claims. He says the people who rage against Israel are supporting all of the things that the Palestinians represent: Rampant anti-Semitism, genocidal ideation, glorification of Jihad, murder of Jews, etc. And that is true. You cannot support a movement without supporting, or being accepting of the outcome of that movement.

Strangely, though, even his ardently pro-Israel stance, anti-Arab stance isn't enough for some, who still label him an antisemite for his atheist opinion that Judaism, like all religions, is false, and that religious claims to Jerusalem should be ignored: Pat Condell is Antisemitic Scum | Jewish Internet Defense Force

The JIDF is nuts, but notice they labeled him anti-semitic scum because he disagreed with settlements. But I know, he's a pro-Israel "shill." BTW, I looked up shill in the dictionary, and that does not describe him at all.
 

The Real

Anti-Ignorance
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
6,353
Reputation
725
Daps
10,724
Reppin
NYC
There is a far leap between "interested in Palestinian issues" and "anti-Zionism."

Also, you're obviously misrepresenting his claims. He says the people who rage against Israel are supporting all of the things that the Palestinians represent: Rampant anti-Semitism, genocidal ideation, glorification of Jihad, murder of Jews, etc. And that is true. You cannot support a movement without supporting, or being accepting of the outcome of that movement.

Well, he claims that the entire Palestinian cause is a "sham" (his words) and that it's being used as a pawn for a giant Muslim conspiracy that wants to destroy Israel and turn the Middle East into a caliphate, and that the entire Western leftist support-base for the Palestinians has been roped into this conspiracy, knowingly or not. That's very different from a straightforward critique of anti-Zionism and antisemitism.

The JIDF is nuts, but notice they labeled him anti-semitic scum because he disagreed with settlements. But I know, he's a pro-Israel "shill." BTW, I looked up shill in the dictionary, and that does not describe him at all.

I think it's fair to call someone who believes that Israel has an indisputable right to exist but that Palestinians do not a shill, breh. I didn't mean it in the conspiratorial sense of the term, so if you want, I'll just be more precise and call him an extremist, but regardless, it doesn't get much more black and white or extreme than that imo.

He disagreed with settlements because he identified the settlements he was discussing as religious in inspiration (which many of them are) and he hates religion and doesn't think it belongs in political claims, not because of anything intrinsic to Jewish people or specific to Judaism, so even if one disagrees, I don't think his view can legitimately be called antisemitic.
 
Joined
Jul 25, 2012
Messages
1,417
Reputation
-155
Daps
811
Reppin
NULL
Well, he claims that the entire Palestinian cause is a "sham" (his words) and that it's being used as a pawn for a giant Muslim conspiracy that wants to destroy Israel and turn the Middle East into a caliphate, and that the entire Western leftist support-base for the Palestinians has been roped into this conspiracy, knowingly or not. That's very different from a straightforward critique of anti-Zionism and antisemitism.

I suppose it depends how you define "an entire cause." It seems like you're defining it by "anyone and everyone who is part of the cause." If you observe the discrepancy between what Palestinian leaders say in Arabic, and what they say in English, you would have no choice but to call their cause a sham.

I think it's fair to call someone who believes that Israel has an indisputable right to exist but that Palestinians do not a shill, breh. I didn't mean it in the conspiratorial sense of the term, so if you want, I'll just be more precise and call him an extremist, but regardless, it doesn't get much more black and white or extreme than that imo.

Opposing a Palestinian state can simply mean "hey, I prefer that Jews don't get brutally murdered just so that the Palestinians can quench their thirst for land." That's not an extremist position at all.

He disagreed with settlements because he identified the settlements he was discussing as religious in inspiration (which many of them are) and he hates religion and doesn't think it belongs in political claims, not because of anything intrinsic to Jewish people or specific to Judaism, so even if one disagrees, I don't think his view can legitimately be called antisemitic.

I agree with you on this point. This is why I said the JIDF was nuts. The point is, he doesn't support everything Israel does.
 

Dusty Bake Activate

Fukk your corny debates
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
39,078
Reputation
5,982
Daps
132,705
Whoa whoa whoaaaaa, im too tough for that bruh. You draw your thin ass Genuine goatee on with eyeliner though you bytch ass nikka. :popcorn:

You put this on your ringworm-infected hairline ever morning, you 50 year old :flabbynsick:-looking lame.

bice.png
 

wize fool

Rookie
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
361
Reputation
0
Daps
66
Reppin
NULL
I see you're in your comfort zone, Vic. Always clowning, never spitting knowledge.
 
Top