Donovan McNabb vs Michael Vick

[Rigby.]

Cam

 

[obarth]

Don of them McSwagb gets my vote. To this day he's the QB I most dreaded facing as a Giants fan.

 

[CanesMiamiLakers]

Dante culpepper>>>> Vick so I voted mcnabb

 

[filial_piety]

As a life long eagles fan...and as someone who remembers when McNabb was drafted, and watched every game that he played in until he left.....

I gotta go McNabb

Before he got injured around 2005, he was pretty elite and carried a do-nothing Eagles offense to 4 straight NFC championships and 1 SB. he had absolutely no weapons until Brian Westbrook got there in like 02' and TO for 1 season in 04/05.

His passing game was slightly above average, and his running/scrambling QB game was top 3.

vick is the GOAT all time scrambling/running QB tho without a doubt, it's the only thing that really keeps him in the discussion.

 

[Bboystyle]

McNabb and its not even close. Anyone who thinks otherwise is an ATL fan or an idiot.

 

[Captain Crunch]

McNabb, but’s Vick’s comeback season was just
That MNF game against McNabb in DC

 

[AVXL]

As a Falcons fan Mike gave us unbelievable highlights and he was a great athlete but McNabb was a better QB. Plus McNabb's Eagles knocked us outta the playoffs twice during the Vick era so unfortunately it's McNabb

 

[Samson]

Vick was far more iconic
McNabb was the better QB.

 

[daboywonder2002]

Without question it's Mcnabb. I mean he had Todd PInkston and James thrash. Had a beautiful deep ball. Went 11-5 on a consistent basis. I love Vick.. That 2011 season was magic.But Vick's biggest accomplishments were the madden cover, the playoff win against green bay and the 2011 season.

The problem is that with Vick, people only focus on his highs and forget all the lows. It's like Vick can do no wrong.

With Mcnabb- they only remember the bad stuff(throwing up in the superbowl, losing in Washington and MInnesota, Vick taking his spot). but they forget all the good he brought to the Eagles.

 

[Nostalgic]

Die hard Atl Falcons fan, This shouldn't be a question

It's McNabb 5 NFC Champ game appearance, Super Bowl appearance
great pocket passer in the ladder stage of his career.

Vick was just an entertaining player to watch. Thats all

 

[The Fire]

Not close

 

[Nostalgic]

The problem is that with Vick, people only focus on his highs and forget all the lows. It's like Vick can do no wrong.

I've always said this about Vick.

If we keepin it a bean Matt Schabb was a better QB than Vick

 

[King Karim]

McNabb but Vick had more raw talent.

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

Vick never threw up in the huddle. I'm going with Mike

 

[Motife43]

McNabb. Both him and Vick did well with mediocre supporting casts offensively. But yeah McNabb gets the nod, better skilled QB compared to Mike Vick