Doctor Who Appreciation Thread

Adeptus Astartes

Loyal servant of the God-Brehmperor
Supporter
Joined
Sep 15, 2019
Messages
11,029
Reputation
2,553
Daps
67,377
Reppin
Imperium of Man
I decided to tune in having not watched in years. I started at the 9th Doctor and watched through the Smith era.

I was looking forward to this, the 10th Doctor and Donna Noble were great. Seeing them onscreen together was a treat. Their chemistry was still there.

The Meep was hilarious and they pulled off the twist. You knew something was off, but I didn't see the absolute heel turn coming. I also liked the subversion of the generic "evil bug-like aliens" pursuing the Meep, but where did they come from? I didn't see a ship. I guess they teleported. It's also heartening to know we'll get to see a few Wilf scenes. :salute:

The politics and agenda were far too heavy handed. A quick Google shows Dr. Who has apparently been "woke" for some time. The wheelchar bound woman seemed like a checkbox, but I liked the 007 Q style wheelchair, and it makes sense that UNIT would have access to tech like that. We get it, trans people exist and the Doctor's regeneration mechanic can be seen as a trans allegory, but....:comeon: The joke about assuming the Meeps gender was ok. It's an alien, we don't know its gender. Donna avoiding death by spreading the vortex power to her child makes sense, but Rose's gender identity being the key to accessing their DoctorDonna powers was groan inducing in its preachiness. I guess we have another River Song. Additionally, I wasn't a big fan of Yasmine's acting. She just didn't have a lot of personality and felt wooden. I'm going to keep watching, but if it stays this open with the agenda, I'm tuning out.

Edit: Just saw that Captain Jack isn't going to show. That sucks.
 
Last edited:

TDT

All Star
Joined
Dec 31, 2014
Messages
3,587
Reputation
477
Daps
6,274
I decided to tune in having not watched in years. I started at the 9th Doctor and watched through the Smith era.

I was looking forward to this, the 10th Doctor and Donna Noble were great. Seeing them onscreen together was a treat. Their chemistry was still there.

The Meep was hilarious and they pulled off the twist. You knew something was off, but I didn't see the absolute heel turn coming. I also liked the subversion of the generic "evil bug-like aliens" pursuing the Meep, but where did they come from? I didn't see a ship. I guess they teleported. It's also heartening to know we'll get to see a few Wilf scenes. :salute:

The politics and agenda were far too heavy handed. A quick Google shows Dr. Who has apparently been "woke" for some time. The wheelchar bound woman seemed like a checkbox, but I liked the 007 Q style wheelchair, and it makes sense that UNIT would have access to tech like that. We get it, trans people exist and the Doctor's regeneration mechanic can be seen as a trans allegory, but....:comeon: The joke about assuming the Meeps gender was ok. It's an alien, we don't know its gender. Donna avoiding death by spreading the vortex power to her child makes sense, but Rose's gender identity being the key to accessing their DoctorDonna powers was groan inducing in its preachiness. I guess we have another River Song. Additionally, I wasn't a big fan of Yasmine's acting. She just didn't have a lot of personality and felt wooden. I'm going to keep watching, but if it stays this open with the agenda, I'm tuning out.

Edit: Just saw that Captain Jack isn't going to show. That sucks.
Yeah i don't think we'll ever see Jack Harkness on Doctor Who or any Torchwood-related media since John Barrowman acted a fool off-set(exposing himself,etc :snoop: )
 

Json

Superstar
Joined
Nov 21, 2017
Messages
12,707
Reputation
1,375
Daps
38,447
Reppin
Central VA
I can’t do it. I made it 15 minutes and just couldn’t deal. I wasn’t a huge 10 fan and only a handful of Donna and Ten episodes I really enjoy.

This was already a slog. I don’t care about Donna’s family drama. I’ll check out second special since it looks like just Donna and 10/14.
 

abominable1

the fukkery, the sweet ,sweet fukkery
Supporter
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
3,791
Reputation
8,229
Daps
9,913
Reppin
@RGM
Got my
pirate-laughing.gif
on

and watched the latest ep live

damned good ep, felt more like a love letter to classic who eps where
where the tardis abandons the doctor for awhile


they acknowledged the Flux this episode
and WILF!!!!!!



I wish this could have been a whole season worth of episodes '
they are really restoring the feeling

cant wait for the next episode and when the next doctor pops up.
 
Last edited:

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
47,701
Reputation
6,602
Daps
133,017
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
I started watching in the 90s but this show is crazy. I wonder if can stream the episodes from the 70s and 80s somewhere.
 

Malcy86

Pro
Joined
Feb 2, 2017
Messages
1,108
Reputation
205
Daps
1,985
Reppin
Glasgow
Thought this episode was a waste of time. I seen so many people convinced it would have 11, Amy, 12, Nardole, Ncuti etc and always knew they wouldn't be in it but was intrigued by this supposedly 'never before done' concept and the press not getting screeners that it would just be unique.

Wrong. It was boring and totally superfluous. Oh and the new 'agenda' is back this week in a 'in your face' way but not a focus.
 

abominable1

the fukkery, the sweet ,sweet fukkery
Supporter
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
3,791
Reputation
8,229
Daps
9,913
Reppin
@RGM
I actually enjoyed this episode
Toymaker was more like Q from Star trek , with a very mean streak.
looking forward to see who the nikka was that made him fall back
Nice seeing Mel Again
Unit rocking the Triskelion was a nice move



the regeneration was unexpected - Bi Generation caused by the toymaker , so now there are 2 doctors , also intersted to see what they do with the master
 

Json

Superstar
Joined
Nov 21, 2017
Messages
12,707
Reputation
1,375
Daps
38,447
Reppin
Central VA
I hated this.

The episode itself was fine but he RTDed all over that ending.

I always wanted them to bring back the random regenerations from the old Who but this is ridiculous. RTD made the same mistake of making his companions so special that we over write to make them happy
 
Top