Ironically only then will some of our Allstars says it’s okay to emerge from their basements to show up to protest
Remember folks, you can only critique people you voted for
It's the main culture war wedge that has teeth and the GQP is going to run it until they lose something but right now it's giving them the margins to win races. There's no win for the Dems on the issue. Voting against it won't help. Voting for it won't help. Abstention won't help.This transgender shyt Nap is posting is getting annoying. I guarantee you in 4 years trans people existing will be the least of our worries.
Ironically only then will some of our Allstars says it’s okay to emerge from their basements to show up to protest
Remember folks, you can only critique people you voted for
The facts of the story here are that Republican/MAGA voters are showing up to these town halls and criticizing the Republican/MAGA politicians that they voted for. Every news story about this centers that fact because it's crucial to the efficacy of the story. These Republicans don't care about critiques from leftists. If AOC and a bunch of leftists were the ones showing up and criticizing, they wouldn't be bytching up, they would be emboldened and weaponize it to show to their voters that they're doing the right thing because the enemy of my enemy. That doesn't mean they shouldn't be protested by leftists, it just means that it's not going to be maximally effective in changing the minds of either these Republican/MAGA politicians or their voters. Just imagine if some right wing anti-abortion or gun rights activists show up to an AOC protest. She's not going to bytch up and change course because they don't represent her ideology or her voter base.Crazy how fast Republicans bytch up once they face a little protesting.. who knew
How do you know it’s only MAGA/Republican voters showing up to protest?The facts of the story here are that Republican/MAGA voters are showing up to these town halls and criticizing the Republican/MAGA politicians that they voted for. Every news story about this centers that fact because it's crucial to the efficacy of the story. These Republicans don't care about critiques from leftists. If AOC and a bunch of leftists were the ones showing up and criticizing, they wouldn't be bytching up, they would be emboldened and weaponize it to show to their voters that they're doing the right thing because the enemy of my enemy. That doesn't mean they shouldn't be protested by leftists, it just means that it's not going to be maximally effective in changing the minds of either these Republican/MAGA politicians or their voters. Just imagine if some right wing anti-abortion or gun rights activists show up to an AOC protest. She's not going to bytch up and change course because they don't represent her ideology or her voter base.
What Tim Walz and Ro Khanna are suggesting is the correct course from the Democrats. Show up and present an actual political alternative to these newly disappointed voters, not just doing ineffective protests of a known enemy. It's not enough for Democrats to say "these are bad guys!" they have to say "this is why we'd be better for you!". The game is to win the voters over to your political program.
You have to sign a paper that says you promise you are a lifelong republican before you enter the town halls.How do you know it’s only MAGA/Republican voters showing up to protest?
And your AOC analogy isn’t a fair comparison, these people are showing up because Republicans are materially making their life worse, it’s a non-partisan issue
Assuming we're talking about these town halls, they're not really being protested so much as Republicans running away from disgruntled constituents. The most prominent examples have all been constituents themselves explicitly mentioning they're Trump voters so they don't get dismissed out of hand by their Republican rep.How do you know it’s only MAGA/Republican voters showing up to protest?
It doesn't matter why they're showing up, it matters who they are and what community they represent. Republican reps aren't showing up to local DSA meetings even though those members are still their constituents. Politics is gerrymandered precisely so politicians on both sides don't have to encounter constituents on the opposite end of the spectrum. If the local VFW shows up to a Republican event and registers their discontent with x policy/result, it doesn't really matter to the politician what x is, what matters to that a loyal, bedrock constituency group is not happy. Same way if Planned Parenthood showed up to register discontent at an AOC event or SEIU shows up to register discontent at a Bernie event. If AOC or Bernie get protested by the NRA, it doesn't matter what the specific issue is because that's not a relevant constituency group for their political program.And your AOC analogy isn’t a fair comparison, these people are showing up because Republicans are materially making their life worse, it’s a non-partisan issue
it's not the actual issue that pisses people off. it's the disrespect being shown to votersIt's the main culture war wedge that has teeth and the GQP is going to run it until they lose something but right now it's giving them the margins to win races. There's no win for the Dems on the issue. Voting against it won't help. Voting for it won't help. Abstention won't help.
Anyone can show up at the town hall. They don’t check your voting records before you’re allowed entry.Assuming we're talking about these town halls, they're not really being protested so much as Republicans running away from disgruntled constituents. The most prominent examples have all been constituents themselves explicitly mentioning they're Trump voters so they don't get dismissed out of hand by their Republican rep.
It doesn't matter why they're showing up, it matters who they are and what community they represent. Republican reps aren't showing up to local DSA meetings even though those members are still their constituents. Politics is gerrymandered precisely so politicians on both sides don't have to encounter constituents on the opposite end of the spectrum. If the local VFW shows up to a Republican event and registers their discontent with x policy/result, it doesn't really matter to the politician what x is, what matters to that a loyal, bedrock constituency group is not happy. Same way if Planned Parenthood showed up to register discontent at an AOC event or SEIU shows up to register discontent at a Bernie event. If AOC or Bernie get protested by the NRA, it doesn't matter what the specific issue is because that's not a relevant constituency group for their political program.
Yes, the Republicans/MAGA voters registering discontent at Republican town halls are complaining about their lives being made materially worse, but if you replace them with DSA complaining about the same thing then the Republicans reps aren't going to care and it would be a non-story because they were never going to get their vote anyway.