Im not surprised critics are like "This is actually good and the dark tone is fun
"
And I also will not be surprised when they and the fans in 2-3 years time will complain about the show falling off despite having the same tone
I dont think its great, it feels patterned and the characters are not really fleshed. It feels like its copied the 2010s teen genre rather than bringing anything unique to it. Homegirl who plays Veronica and the other one who played the teacher are cute but Archie all pale as a vampire looks weird, None of the characters had charm or interest
CW can do this but it doesn't mean its good.
Still I'mma let the people who dig it cook