Conservative Group Files Lawsuit - Complains That Loan Forgiveness Will Narrow Wealth Gap For Black People
- Thread starter jwinfield
- Start date
ORDER_66
Demon Time coming 2024
Lets be real it wont close the wealth gap... I mean realistically it's a fukking start but they have millions born into wealth you know what type of money it would take for us as a collective to catch up???
Black folks always living rent free in their minds. This is dumb as hell and should be thrown out .. even when given crumbs they think it’s too much for us. It’s tiring. I’m tired. White folks are just gross ..and weird.
OperationNumbNutts
Superstar
Saying forgiving up to $20k in student loan forgiveness with help close the racial gap is laughable.
Pull Up the Roots
I have a good time when I go out of my mind..
It's crazy how these threads always go ignored by a certain crowd.
SupaDupaFresh
Superstar
Can any of our socially conservative brehs chime in here?
DatBoiHawk
HAWK
not the first time.
Da whites to sue the Biden Adminastration for giving tangibles to Black Farmers...
TEXAS AGRICULTURE COMMISSIONER SUES BIDEN ADMINISTRATION ALLEGING AID TO BLACK FARMERS DISCRIMINATES AGAINST WHITE FARMERS Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller is suing the federal government, claiming the aid to Black farmers as part of the Biden administration’s COVID-19 relief plan...
www.thecoli.com
Trump allies wage legal war against black farmer aid; claim reverse discrimination #BothSides
Biden dropped the bag for black farmers. Trump is trying to make sure black farmers DONT get that money. #BothSides, tho right? :sas1: On behalf of white farmers, Trump allies wage legal war against equity On behalf of white farmers, Trump allies wage legal war against equity...
www.thecoli.com
Kingofthereal
King of kings
Whites don’t want the playing field leveled for blacks. They know if the playing field was leveled we would surpass them and everyone else. Whites praise mediocrity amongst each other and blacks know this so we push ourselves to be better at almost everything.
Renegade47
Superstar
it will lower the debt to income ratio allowing people to be able to get loans for homes. so it does actually help a little. not enough tho
The hilarious part about this lawsuit is the fact that I'm sure that their kids/grandkids will apply for the same loan forgiveness that they're complaining about.
get these nets
Veteran
Very few if any conservatives are on this forum.
Just some low intelligence guys who get their views, talking points, and words from YTers. Because they don't think for themselves, they can't react or comment about any of this stuff.
That group in Wisconsin is behind a lot of these lawsuits. Just made a thread about them appealing a decision in a suit they brought challenging college grants for minority groups.
Wisconsin conservative group is trying to block college grant for minority students
Conservative law firm to appeal judge's dismissal of lawsuit arguing minority retention grant discriminates against white students, others Sept 26. 2022 A conservative law firm said it will appeal a judge's decision to dismiss its case challenging the constitutionality of a college grant...
www.thecoli.com
Biden's student loan plan explicitly and illegally helps Black borrow…
Danielle Douglas-Gabriel
Conservative lawyer Rick Esenberg is backing a lawsuit to overturn President Biden’s student debt relief plan, claiming the president lacks the authority and is violating the law by explicitly helping Black borrowers. (Scott Bauer/AP)
A group in Wisconsin claims President Biden’s plan to cancel up to $20,000 in student loan debt violates federal law by intentionally seeking to narrow the racial wealth gap and help Black borrowers.
The allegation is among the claims in a lawsuit filed Tuesday by conservative legal outfit Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty on behalf of the Brown County Taxpayers Association. The complaint largely relies on arguments of executive overreach that have been raised in other legal actions to block Biden’s plan.
It stands out, however, by also bringing race into the mix.
In promoting the debt forgiveness plan, the White House has said it could help narrow the racial wealth gap and advance racial equity. But the lawsuit argues that those statements constitute an “improper racial motive” and violate the constitution’s guarantee of equal protection of the laws.
Story continues below advertisement
“The White House has indicated that one reason to do this is that they believe it would disproportionately benefit certain racial groups,” said Rick Esenberg, president and general counsel of the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty. “The racial motivation supports these taxpayers standing to challenge [the policy] and informs yet another constitutional difficulty with the program.”
The president’s policy would cancel up to $10,000 in federal student loan debt for borrowers who earn less than $125,000 per year, or less than $250,000 for married couples. Those who received Pell Grants, federal aid for lower-income students, could see up to $20,000 forgiven.
There are no racial criteria for loan forgiveness. But because of the disparities in who holds student loans, the cancellation policy could have an outsize effect on Black borrowers, who shoulder a disproportionate share of the debt and frequently receive Pell Grants because of a lack of financial resources to attend college.
[The faces of student debt]
“Student loan policies have had a discriminatory impact and student debt cancellation helps to remedy some of that discriminatory impact, but this is a race-neutral policy,” said Abby Shafroth, director of the National Consumer Law Center’s Student Loan Borrower Assistance Project.
Story continues below advertisement
Who is eligible for student loan forgiveness?
Genevieve Bonadies Torres of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law said the lawsuit “turns the equal protection clause on its head,” as the mere awareness of race or a disproportionate impact does not amount to a violation of the law. She said conservative groups have unsuccessfully used similar arguments to challenge high school admissions policies that expand access for marginalized students.
“I can think of a host of policies and practices that disproportionately help White people that, again, are not being put under the legal microscope,” Bonadies Torres said. The lawsuit “is indicative of the attacks that we’re seeing on any opportunities that try to get people relief that they’re due.”
Targeting relief to borrowers with the greatest economic need, the White House has said, could address the racial wealth disparity. The administration has also noted the benefits to borrowers of all ages and those from low- and middle-income households. It has framed the plan as a way to give Americans a stronger financial footing coming out of the pandemic.
Story continues below advertisement
White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said Tuesday that the president is making good on a campaign commitment to help more than 40 million Americans mired in student debt and people affected by the economic upheaval caused by the global health crisis.
“It’s a shame that you have Republican groups, Republican states that are trying to stop Americans from getting a little bit of breathing room, a little bit of a break,” Jean-Pierre said during a press briefing. “It is shameful that they are siding with the special interests. It is shameful they are not siding with the American people. This is one of the ways the president is going to continue to work for the American people.”
The Biden administration has been adamant that it has the legal authority to cancel student debt, citing a 2003 law giving the executive branch broad authority to overhaul student loan programs. It is facing several legal challenges, including one from a coalition of six Republican-led states, that could delay or halt the implementation of the policy.
Story continues below advertisement
The Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty and other conservative advocacy groups argue that Biden’s policy represents illegal executive overreach because the 2003 law was created to give the president authority after a disaster like the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. The group also asserts that the executive branch lacks the authority to create a new forgiveness policy and is usurping Congress’s power to make law.
“The issue isn’t as simple as whether you like student loan forgiveness or you don’t like student loan forgiveness. It’s also whether you really want to create a precedent where a president of the United States will have this kind of authority,” Esenberg said. “Process and the rule of law matters.”
Danielle Douglas-Gabriel covers the economics of higher education, writing about the financial policies that determine a student's access to education and ability to complete a credential. Twitter
