Gotta agree here... "I Used To Love HER" was dope, but in terms of the average everyday person listening to and following rap at the time, I don't think Common was an unanimous vote as one of the best out there. It's just like how there are message board favorites, and then you go outside and a lotta niqqas never heard of these dudes. I would say in that time compared to the artists that were really gettin' love, Common was a nice MC amongst other nice MCs that also weren't getting a major amount of attention. Common was O.C., Common was Organized Konfusion, Common was Casual, Kurious, dudes like that. Not super-underground, but not about to be the next big thing either. In terms of people that your regular hip-hop listenin' niqqas were into, I wouldn't even say he was on par with Black Moon, Smif-n-Wessun, Jeru or any of those types.
That bein' said, "I Used To Love HER" pretty much saved his career. I can't imagine that without that record meaning what it meant, he would've seen album #3.