The "baby" moves back as an adult with her husband into the house where her parents were murdered, she starts talking with the murderer-who's now in prison- and as soon as she arrives murders start back up, with the new killer (who they call The Executioner) using the same costume as the original killer. Thus far there's a murder every episode and they go over old mysteries/disappearances, a lot of incidents are connected. It forces the Biblical angle with the deadly sins and related punishments but there are some
interesting bits you learn about the citizens-for example, the daughter found and watched tapes of her mom getting banged out by nearly half the town including women

. There are a
lot of deaths for it to be a small town and they're creative with the killings.