Ultimately for me in these discussions, the most weight is on one thing: Public reception.
I think 187 He Wrote is much better than the self-titled version, and I think most who have heard both would agree.
However, the self-title album got MUCH burn. First time I ever heard of Spice 1, I was in the barber shop reading a Jet
magazine...always flipped to the back because it had "The Weeks Best Albums" and "The Weeks Best Singles" in there.
Spice 1 - Spice 1 was number 1 this particular week...mind you, this was over Luther Vandross, Death Certificate,
Mariah Carey's first album, 2Pacalypse Now, Luke, and Public Enemy. As we started hearing the songs, the rep got bigger.
Understand: ask most people what they know about Spice 1 in general, and what would they say?
- he's the East Bay Reggae Gangster
- the stutter flow
- "coolin' on the corner with the cellular phone..."
- he kicked off the brand-naming songs
...all that is from the first album.
I like almost all of Spice's albums more than the first one, but it's the one that got the most reach.